BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →
Dear Doug Collins

Alwyn Cashe: The Man Who Walked Through Fire, and the Sixteen Years It Took to Say So

Alwyn C. Cashe did everything his country asked, and then he did the thing no order can produce: on fire himself, he went back into a burning vehicle again and again until his soldiers were out. This page is the documented record of what he did near Samarra, Iraq, in 2005, what his own institution did about it afterward, and the fight his sister carried for sixteen years — told in dates, findings, and the Army's own words.

The service, and the promise

Alwyn Cashe enlisted in the U.S. Army on July 18, 1989, shortly after graduating from Oviedo High School in Florida, where he had grown up. He joined as a supply specialist, served in Korea, and in 1993 became an infantryman. He served as a squad leader at Fort Hood and in Germany, graduated from Drill Sergeant School in 1998 and spent more than two years as a drill sergeant at Fort Benning, Georgia, and served a further tour in Germany before, in April 2004, becoming a platoon sergeant in the 3rd Brigade, 3rd Infantry Division, at Fort Benning.

His deployments, by the Army’s own record, were the Gulf War in 1991, the 2003 invasion of Iraq, and a return to Iraq in 2005 in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom. By then he was Sergeant First Class Alwyn C. Cashe, platoon sergeant with Company A, 1st Battalion, 15th Infantry Regiment, 3rd Brigade, 3rd Infantry Division.

The promise made to men like Alwyn Cashe is the oldest one in the profession: no one is left behind. It is the creed he was known for living by. His battalion commander, Lt. Gen. Gary Brito, later put it in the Army’s official account: “You don’t often find truly selfless sacrifice where someone put his Soldiers’ welfare before his own. Sgt. [1st Class] Cashe was horribly wounded and continued to fight to save his men.” What follows is what that creed looked like when it was tested — and what it took to get his country to say, on the record, what he had actually done.

What happened — October 17, 2005

On the night of October 17, 2005, Cashe was on a mounted patrol near Samarra, in Salah Ad Din Province, Iraq, commanding a Bradley Fighting Vehicle. What happened next is established by his Medal of Honor citation, the Army’s official account of the action:

The Army’s summary of the action records the full count plainly: Cashe retrieved six soldiers and an Iraqi interpreter from the burning vehicle, receiving burns on nearly 72% of his body. When the medical evacuation helicopters arrived, the citation records, he refused evacuation until all of the other wounded soldiers had been evacuated first.

He was flown, by stages, to Brooke Army Medical Center in San Antonio, Texas. His sister, Kasinal Cashe White, was at his bedside there, and spent, in the Associated Press’s words, “the last three most precious weeks of his life with him.” When he regained the ability to speak, those who were with him — and President Biden, retelling it at the medal ceremony sixteen years later — record the same first concern: “How are my boys?”

SFC Alwyn C. Cashe died of his wounds on November 8, 2005. He was 35 years old. Not every soldier he pulled from the Bradley survived his own burns; the Army’s remembrance of Cashe notes that each of them made it back to the United States for treatment, which is what his trips into the fire bought them, and their families.

What the institution did afterward

Cashe was awarded the Silver Star, the nation’s third-highest decoration for valor. His battalion commander, Gary Brito, had made that recommendation himself — and, by the record that later emerged, he had made it without knowing the full extent of what Cashe had done or how badly he was burned. The witnesses who could have told the whole story had themselves been evacuated for medical care. As the fuller account came together, Brito did something commanders do not always do: he set out to correct his own recommendation. Military Times reported that Brito “spent years gathering firsthand eyewitness statements and rallying support” for an upgrade to the Medal of Honor.

Contemporary reporting records a second obstacle in the early paperwork: the first accounts of the attack left out the enemy gunfire that had raked the ground around Cashe as he worked — a detail that mattered, because the Medal of Honor requires action against an enemy. Later investigations restored it. The citation, when it finally came, states it in its first paragraph: the Bradley was attacked by small-arms fire and an IED.

The campaign outlasted administrations. Kasinal Cashe White carried it from the family side for the whole of it. “I think I led the campaign for the last 16 years,” she told reporters on the eve of the ceremony. “I’ve been a spokesperson for it, written letters and called people, and just did everything I could, jumped through whatever hoops, to get his award upgraded.” Brito’s support, she said, was validating — the institution’s own witness, arguing the family’s case from inside.

An act of Congress, sixteen years on, to permit the country to say what the men who were there had been saying since 2005.

Where it stands now

Cashe was the first Black service member to receive the Medal of Honor since the Vietnam War — a fact the Army, the Department of Veterans Affairs, and the White House each record. He was, the VA notes, the 93rd Black service member awarded the medal, and the first recognized for actions in Iraq.

The institution got there. It got there sixteen years late, over incomplete paperwork, a missing fact, and an expired clock — and only because a sister spent those sixteen years refusing to let the file close, and a commander spent them arguing against his own first decision. Before the medal came, the 3rd Infantry Division had already renamed its ceremonial grounds at Fort Stewart Cashe Gardens (May 20, 2021), with his family and division leaders unveiling the sign together. His name is now in the Hall of Heroes and over the division’s parade ground. What his family asked for was never complicated: that the record say what he did. At last, in the citation’s own words, it does — that he showed “extraordinary heroism and selflessness above and beyond the call of duty.”

That is the pattern this site exists to document. The medal was earned in a single night, in fire. Getting his country to say so took sixteen years, a sister who would not quit, and an act of Congress.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

The record, on video

Cashe’s story was carried for years by the people who knew it first — his family, his soldiers, his command — before it was ever carried by a ceremony. Four films: the ceremony, the Army’s documentary tribute, the service’s portrait of the recipient, and his hometown hearing the news.

The ceremony. President Biden presents the Medal of Honor to Tamara Cashe at the White House on December 16, 2021 — sixteen years after Samarra, in the ceremony shared with Christopher Celiz and Earl Plumlee. (U.S. Army video.)

The tribute. Fort Benning's full documentary: five people whose lives were touched by Alwyn Cashe remember his life, his loyalty, and the night that led to the medal. (U.S. Army video, MCoE Fort Benning.)

The recipient. The Army's portrait of Cashe — "a soldier's soldier," in the words spoken over his citation, told by the men who served beside him. (U.S. Army video.)

The hometown. Oviedo, Florida hears the news, December 2021: the local soldier whose family had waited sixteen years would receive the Medal of Honor. (WKMG News 6, Orlando.)

Sources

Further record

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed. Videos are embedded from their publishers; nothing here is re-hosted.