IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Norma Carroll: The Widow the Filing Window Closed Before the Government Conceded the Disease

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Norma Carroll did everything in the order the government later said she should have — except one thing, on a calendar she had no reason to watch. She was married to a veteran for 43 years. He died of a disease the Department of Veterans Affairs would eventually presume, by regulation, to be connected to military service. But by the time the VA adopted that presumption, the one-year window Congress had opened for widows in her position had been closed for almost four years, and every institution that reviewed her claim — the VA regional office, the Board of Veterans' Appeals, the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims, and the Federal Circuit — told her the same thing: she was too late. This page is that sequence, in the record's own dates and words.

The service, and the promise

Norma D. Carroll married veteran Glenn Dodson in 1949. The couple remained married for 43 years, until Mr. Dodson’s death in 1992. The Federal Circuit’s opinion records the cause plainly: he died of cardiac arrhythmia due to amyotrophic lateral sclerosis — ALS.

The promise at issue here is not a speech or a poster. It is a statute. Under 38 U.S.C. §§ 1310–1318, the United States pays Dependency and Indemnity Compensation — DIC — to the surviving spouse of a veteran whose death resulted from a service-related injury or disease: if service caused the death, the government will not leave the surviving spouse with nothing.

Mrs. Carroll’s case was never decided on whether that promise applied to her husband’s death. No adjudicator in the record reached the merits of whether Glenn Dodson’s ALS was service-connected. Her case was decided, at every level, on timing — on who counted as a “surviving spouse,” and on a filing deadline that ran out before the evidentiary rule that would have mattered most to her claim existed. The institutions that denied her did not say her husband’s death was unrelated to his service. They said she had asked in the wrong year.

What happened

In the two years following Mr. Dodson’s death, Mrs. Carroll did not seek DIC benefits. The record gives no reason, and this page will not invent one.

In 1994, two years after Mr. Dodson’s death, Mrs. Carroll remarried, at the age of 64. Under the law as it then stood, that remarriage ended her status. The Federal Circuit stated it directly: her eligibility for DIC benefits terminated upon her remarriage in 1994, because at the time, an individual who remarried could not be considered a surviving spouse under the statute — the opinion cites 38 U.S.C. § 103 as it stood in 1986. Whatever claim she might have made as Glenn Dodson’s widow, the remarriage foreclosed it under the rules then in force.

Nearly ten years later, Congress changed the rule. On December 16, 2003, Congress enacted the Veterans Benefits Act of 2003, Public Law No. 108-183. Section 101(a) of the Act amended Title 38, codified at 38 U.S.C. § 103(d)(2)(B), to provide that “the remarriage after age 57 of the surviving spouse of a veteran shall not bar the furnishing of [certain benefits, including DIC] to such person as the surviving spouse of the veteran.” The House Committee Report accompanying the Act, the Federal Circuit noted, had expressed concern that the existing statute discouraged older spouses from remarrying; the amendment sought to remove that disincentive.

For spouses who remarried after the Act passed, the change was straightforward. For spouses like Mrs. Carroll — already remarried, after age 57, before enactment — Congress attached a condition. Section 101(e) of the Act, an uncodified provision, provided that such an individual “shall be eligible for such benefits by reason of such amendment only if the individual submits an application for such benefits to the Secretary of Veterans Affairs not later than the end of the one-year period beginning on the date of the enactment of this Act.” Mrs. Carroll did not apply during that window. The Federal Circuit fixed its closing date: December 16, 2004.

During that window, ALS, the opinion records, “was recognized as a condition that could be service-related, though not presumptively so,” citing 38 C.F.R. § 4.124a (2004). A widow who had applied in 2004 would have had to prove, on her individual evidence, that her husband’s ALS was connected to his service. There was no presumption to carry that burden.

That changed on September 23, 2008, when the VA promulgated the regulation establishing a presumption of service connection for ALS. Published at 73 Federal Register 54,691, the interim final rule established, at what became 38 C.F.R. § 3.318, that the development of ALS at any time after separation from service is sufficient to establish service connection. Its stated basis was a November 2006 report by the National Academy of Sciences Institute of Medicine on the association between active service and ALS. The rule was adopted as final the following year, applicable to applications received on or after September 23, 2008.

In 2009, after the presumption existed, Mrs. Carroll filed an application for DIC benefits as Mr. Dodson’s widow.

The sequence is the whole case, and it is worth stating without adornment. The filing window for previously remarried spouses closed on December 16, 2004. The presumption that ALS is service-connected took effect on September 23, 2008. Mrs. Carroll applied in 2009. The door Congress opened had closed almost four years before the government conceded, as a general rule, the very fact her claim would have had to prove.

What the institution did afterward

The VA regional office denied Mrs. Carroll’s claim because, in the Federal Circuit’s summary, “she submitted her application nearly five years after the close of the one-year filing window for previously remarried spouses created by § 101(e) of the 2003 Act.” She appealed to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals. The Board denied her claim for the same reason.

She appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims — the Veterans Court — in case No. 12-2585, before Judge Alan G. Lance, Sr. There she made the argument her case turned on: that § 101(e) applied only to individuals who would have been eligible for DIC in 2003 but for their remarriage, and was therefore inapplicable to her, because she was not eligible at that time — her husband’s death was not then deemed service-connected. The Veterans Court rejected it. It found, in the Federal Circuit’s account, that her argument “conflated the concepts of entitlement and eligibility”: although she was not necessarily entitled to DIC in 2003, she was eligible to be considered for it on the basis of her prior marriage, and the absence of a presumption did not place her outside § 101(e). On July 18, 2013, the Veterans Court affirmed, in an unpublished disposition, Carroll v. Shinseki, No. 12-2585, 2013 WL 3751775.

Mrs. Carroll appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The case was heard by a panel of Chief Judge Prost and Circuit Judges Clevenger and Chen; Judge Chen wrote the opinion. The government in the case was represented by the Secretary of Veterans Affairs, Robert A. McDonald — the caption’s McDonald, named in his official capacity as Secretary, as is standard in these appeals.

On appeal, Mrs. Carroll refined the argument. She contended that she was not eligible for benefits until 2008, when the VA relaxed the evidentiary burden for establishing service connection for ALS; that before that point the basis of her eligibility did not exist in law, and without the presumption it would have been difficult to establish the service connection DIC required. She argued that the court’s earlier decision in Frederick v. Shinseki, 684 F.3d 1263 (Fed. Cir. 2012), did not apply to her because she never had any eligibility to lose.

The Secretary argued the opposite reading: that “eligible for benefits” in § 101(e) refers to the class of persons who would be recognized as surviving spouses by virtue of the 2003 amendment but for having previously remarried — not limited to those who had already shown, or could necessarily show, that they met every criterion for entitlement on their individual facts.

On September 24, 2014, the Federal Circuit ruled for the Secretary. Its reasoning, in its own documented steps, was this:

The conclusion followed in one sentence: “Because Mrs. Carroll is a member of that class, her eligibility for DIC benefits terminated when the one-year filing window of § 101(e) closed on December 16, 2004.” The judgment of the Veterans Court was affirmed. Costs: no costs. The decision is reported as Carroll v. McDonald, 767 F.3d 1368 (Fed. Cir. 2014).

No part of that holding disputes the marriage, the death, or the disease. The court did not find that ALS is unrelated to service — by 2014, the VA’s own regulation presumed the connection. The holding is narrower: whatever the merits might have been, the class Congress created in 2003 was temporary, her membership in it was not in doubt, and its window had closed before the presumption that defined her claim came into being.

Where it stands now

On the sources opened for this page, the documented record ends with the Federal Circuit’s affirmance of September 24, 2014. Her 2009 application stands denied at every level that reviewed it. No later reversal, award, or reopening appears in the sources this page rests on, and this page will not speculate beyond them.

What can be stated from the record is the structure that produced the result. A surviving spouse who remarried after age 57 before December 16, 2003, was eligible under the 2003 Act only if she applied by December 16, 2004. That deadline was fixed by the date of enactment; it did not move when the VA’s evidentiary rules moved. The 2008 ALS presumption, applicable to applications received on or after September 23, 2008, created no new window for the class the 2003 Act had time-limited, and the Federal Circuit held in 2014 that the 2003 provision was not to be read as if it had.

So the record closes on an arithmetic no adjudicator disputed. A marriage of 43 years, from 1949 to 1992. A remarriage in 1994 that ended eligibility under the law of that day. A statutory fix in 2003 whose window closed in 2004. A presumption in 2008 that the disease her husband died of is connected to service. An application in 2009, denied as untimely, and affirmed in 2014 because the statute does not contemplate “such shifting circumstances.” Norma Carroll was not denied because the government proved her husband’s death had nothing to do with his service. She was denied because two of the government’s own clocks did not overlap.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought


Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door