IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

The Seminole Negro Indian Scouts: Forty-Four Years of Service, Paid in Eviction

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

They were the finest trackers on the Texas frontier, and the Army that employed them said so. For forty-four years the Seminole Negro Indian Scouts rode out of Fort Clark against Comanche, Apache, and Kickapoo raiders, and in their famous campaigns under Lieutenant John L. Bullis they never lost a man. They had come north from Mexico on a promise: land, rations, and pay. The pay came. The rations were cut while their families starved. The land never came at all. And when the Army was finished with them, it disbanded the scouts and put their families — a community of more than two hundred people — off the reservation their service had made home. This page is the documented record.

The service, and the promise

The men who became the scouts were Black Seminoles: descendants of enslaved Africans who had escaped bondage in the American South and found refuge among the Seminole Indians of Spanish Florida. They had fought beside the Seminoles against the United States in the Seminole Wars, been removed west to Indian Territory, and finally — unwilling to be re-enslaved or to live under the authority of slaveholding Creek neighbors — had followed their leader John Horse south into Mexico around 1850. Mexico, which had abolished slavery, employed them as a border militia and granted them land at Nacimiento de los Negros in Coahuila. It is worth pausing on that: the first government that made these people an offer kept it.

In 1870, the United States Army sent word to John Horse, inviting him and his band to come back across the Rio Grande and enlist as Indian scouts against the raiding parties then striking the Texas frontier. About two hundred people accepted the agreement, believing — as the record of their understanding has come down — that they would be granted land in the United States, food and provisions for their families, and reimbursement for their travel. The first group crossed the border on July 4, 1870: John Kibbetts and ten other men, with their families, arriving at Fort Duncan near Eagle Pass. In August 1870 the Army formally created the Seminole Negro Indian Scouts. More families followed through the 1870s. In July 1872 the detachment moved to Fort Clark, near Brackettville, where the scouts’ families built jacales — wattle-and-daub houses — along Las Moras Creek, in a settlement on the reservation known as the camp. The scout community at Fort Clark numbered more than two hundred people. The detachment itself never held more than about fifty enlisted men at any one time; across its whole existence, some 152 men served in its ranks.

The promise, as the scouts and their officers understood it, was plain: scout for the United States, and the United States will settle you on land of your own, feed your families while you ride, and pay you a soldier’s wage. The men would keep that bargain for forty-four years.

What happened

What the scouts did on the frontier is not in dispute, because the Army recorded it. From 1873 to 1881, under Lieutenant John Lapham Bullis of the 24th Infantry, the detachment fought in twenty-six campaigns and expeditions — a dozen of them as part of major operations — ranging into Mexico, the Indian Territory, and Kansas, against Comanche, Kiowa, Lipan Apache, and Kickapoo parties, frequently outnumbered. In all those years of Bullis’s command, the scouts never lost a man killed or wounded in action. They rode with Colonel Ranald Mackenzie’s 4th Cavalry, including the punitive expedition across the border to Remolino in May 1873, and they served alongside the Black regulars of the 24th and 25th Infantry and the 9th and 10th Cavalry — the Buffalo Soldiers.

Four scouts earned the Medal of Honor, the nation’s highest decoration for valor. Three of them — Sergeant John Ward, Private Pompey Factor, and Trumpeter Isaac Payne — received it for riding in under enemy fire in 1875 to rescue Bullis himself, their commander, whose horse had been shot from under him. The fourth, Private Adam Paine, earned his in a separate action. No other word for the service exists in the Army’s own vocabulary: it was gallant, it was sustained, and it was, by the measure of frontier warfare, nearly bloodless on their own side because they were that good at it.

While the men scouted, their families lived on the reservation at Las Moras Creek, in the camp the Army had assigned them — wives, children, and elders of a community that had already been displaced from Florida, from Indian Territory, and from everything except the land Mexico had given them and they had left behind on the Army’s word. The families are the case on this page, because the families are where the promise was broken first and worst. The men were gone for weeks at a time on expeditions. The families ate what the government issued. And the government stopped issuing it.

What the institution did afterward

Take the three terms of the bargain in order.

The land was never granted. The scouts had been promised land in return for their service. No written record of that agreement survived — a fact the government later found convenient. Prominent officers, including men who had commanded the scouts, endorsed their claims to land. The War Department’s answer, preserved in the National Park Service’s account, was that it “had no land that it could legally give them.” Worse, registration for the rolls of the Seminole tribe had closed in 1866 — four years before the Army recruited the scouts — which left the Black Seminoles in Texas and Mexico ineligible for Indian reservation lands altogether. The institution had recruited men with a promise it simultaneously maintained it had no legal power to keep, and it maintained that position for forty-four years, through every appeal the scouts and their own officers filed.

The rations were cut, and the families starved. The Bureau of Indian Affairs reversed its policy toward the Black Seminoles and concluded — in the phrase the descendants’ record preserves — that there was no such thing as a Black Indian. On that reasoning, the families’ rations were cut. The scouts were receiving Medals of Honor in the same years their families were going hungry on the reservation of the fort they defended; accounts preserved by the Park Service record that, without rations, some of the Seminole people resorted to killing stray cattle for food. The government that could not decide whether these people were Indians entitled to support had no difficulty deciding they were soldiers obligated to ride.

In 1914, the Army finished the matter. With the frontier wars a generation past, the War Department ordered the detachment disbanded. The official disbandment order reads, in part: “The Seminole Negro Indian Scouts will be disbanded and cease to exist as an organization after September 30, 1914.” The discharges came in detachments — the first on July 31, 1914, the last on September 30 — and the families were moved off the Fort Clark Military Reservation in waves, between August 1 and 15 and again between October 1 and 15, 1914, “with all of their stock and belongings.” Twenty-seven elderly people were permitted to remain on the reservation only “until the older people pass away in the course of nature, or until such time as the War Department may see fit to order their removal.” In the community’s own memory, preserved in Jeff Guinn’s oral history of the Seminole Negro, they were marched off the grounds of Fort Clark at gunpoint after decades of distinguished service, because the government “had no more use for them, or for the agreement the tribe believed had guaranteed them land of their own in return for their service.”

A community of more than two hundred people — the families of men who had served the United States for forty-four years, four of whom held its highest medal — was evicted from the only home most of them had known. Some families returned to Mexico, to the land at Nacimiento that Mexico had granted and never revoked. Some moved to Oklahoma. Many stayed in Brackettville, in sight of the fort, with nothing.

Where it stands now

The land has never been granted. No federal recognition as a tribe has ever been extended to the Black Seminoles as a people — as Windy Goodloe, secretary of the Seminole Indian Scouts Cemetery Association, has put it, the government and the Bureau of Indian Affairs have treated people as either one thing or the other, and the Black Seminoles will not drop the “Black” from who they are. The appeals their officers endorsed in the nineteenth century were never answered with land in the twentieth or the twenty-first.

What exists instead is what the descendants built themselves. The Seminole Indian Scouts Cemetery at Brackettville was established on the Fort Clark Reservation on September 1, 1872 — two years after the first scouts arrived, while the service was young. More than one hundred scouts are buried there, with their families and descendants, including all four Medal of Honor recipients, under government headstones. The Seminole Indian Scouts Cemetery Association — about two hundred descendant members — maintains the ground, and it makes burial plots available to all Black Seminole descendants free of charge. Every year, on the third weekend in September — the anniversary of the disbandment — the descendants return for Seminole Days: roughly two hundred of them, from as far as Alaska, Ohio, California, and Mexico, for a parade, history seminars, a dance, and a ceremony at the cemetery, where a small American flag is placed before each scout’s headstone. There is a museum. There are Texas legislative resolutions, as recent as 2023 and 2025, honoring the scouts’ descendants and their keeping of the record. The last scout, Curly Jefferson, died in 1959. The record is kept now entirely by the families — which is to say, by the same people the government put off the reservation in 1914.

The Army got forty-four years, twenty-six campaigns, and four Medals of Honor out of the Seminole Negro Indian Scouts. The scouts got a cemetery their own descendants tend. Both of those facts are the record.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members, veterans, and families their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door