Congress, the Courts, and the Coverage
The VA's risk-management record does not live only inside the VA. Congress has held hearings on it, its watchdogs have testified about it under oath, families have fought it in federal court — where judges have split over how far the statutory seal reaches — and reporters have totaled what it costs. This page collects that outside record, linked to its sources.
In Congress
Sacred Obligation: Restoring Veteran Trust and Patient Safety — House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs, May 3, 2011 (Serial No. 112-10). A full-committee hearing after exposure incidents at Dayton, St. Louis, and Miami put thousands of veterans at risk of infection. Chairman Jeff Miller opened it: “the patient safety culture in VA is fractured and accountability and leadership at the helm are lacking.” The committee heard from the Under Secretary for Health, the OIG, and the GAO in a single sitting.
Analyzing VA’s Actions to Prevent Legionnaires’ Disease in Pittsburgh — Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, February 5, 2013 (Serial No. 113-1). The Pittsburgh outbreak: per the CDC findings examined at the hearing, five veterans died over two years from a disease acquired inside the hospital built to treat them, and outside experts testified the deaths were preventable.
VA Patient Safety: Initiatives Promising but Continued Progress Requires Culture Change — GAO testimony (GAO/T-HEHS-00-167), July 27, 2000. A quarter-century ago the GAO was already telling Congress that the VA’s mandatory adverse-event reporting was a work in progress and that progress “requires culture change.” Measure everything since against that sentence.
Statement of Dr. John D. Daigh Jr., Assistant Inspector General for Healthcare Inspections — VA OIG testimony, June 15, 2006. The OIG told Congress that facilities’ processes for disclosing adverse events to patients were inconsistent, and recommended a consistent definition of what must be disclosed across peer review, morbidity-and-mortality, and patient-safety reviews. The disclosure findings on the watchdog record page are what that warning looks like, twenty years on.
Statement of David Case, Acting Inspector General — VA OIG testimony before the Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, February 6, 2025. Testimony on accountability failures, including leaders’ reliance on inaccurate assurances about high-risk patient consults and corrective recommendations that included disclosure of an adverse event.
Statement of Julie Kroviak, MD, Principal Deputy Assistant Inspector General — VA OIG testimony, April 2, 2025. The OIG testified to cases where a required institutional disclosure was never completed — including Tuscaloosa, where leaders said no disclosure was done because the patient died off-site — and where a root cause analysis item was closed as “not feasible” without informing facility leaders.
In the courts: the fight over the seal
When a family sues over VA care under the Federal Tort Claims Act, the first fight is usually not about the medicine. It is about § 5705 — whether the family may see the institution’s own reviews of what happened. Federal district courts have answered both ways.
Maki v. United States — U.S. District Court, Western District of Virginia (2008) (case summary). An FTCA wrongful-death suit over care at the Salem VA. The court held the root cause analysis and the hospital incident report privileged under § 5705 and the peer reviews protected as work product — but ordered the VA OIG’s investigative reports produced.
Salazar v. United States — U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York (2018) (case summary). The court denied the plaintiffs’ motion to compel a VA hospital’s internal report, holding it confidential and privileged under § 5705 and 38 C.F.R. § 17.501 as the product of an “occurrence screening” under VA policy.
Bethel v. United States — U.S. District Court, District of Colorado (2007) (case summary). The other direction: the court ordered the VA to produce most of the withheld quality-assurance and peer-review documents, because the United States had failed to prove the § 5705 privilege applied — the documents had not been designated as protected or were prepared before any claim. Blanket claims of the seal, rejected.
The Anderson judgment, Atlanta — In April 2025, U.S. District Judge Amy Totenberg awarded $8.7 million to the family of Jesse James Anderson, a Vietnam veteran who died after a feeding tube was placed in his windpipe at the Atlanta VA. As reported in coverage of the judgment, the government admitted liability only in June 2024 — nearly eight years after his death — and the judge sanctioned the government in August 2024 for a “lengthy course of concealment.” The medicine failed first. Then the handling became its own wrong, in a federal judge’s words.
In the coverage: what it costs
Veterans Malpractice Payouts Reach 12-Year High on Taxpayer Tab — Bloomberg, reported September 9, 2013 (via Claims Journal). From VA records obtained under FOIA: the government paid $91.7 million to resolve VA malpractice claims in 2012, “the highest sum in at least 12 years,” and taxpayers had spent at least $700 million to resolve claims against the agency since 2001.
Department of Veterans Affairs Pays Out More Than $800M for Malpractice — Associated Press, reporting the Cox Media Group / Dayton Daily News investigation of federal Treasury data, November 14, 2013 (via Claims Journal). Roughly $845 million paid since 2003 to 4,426 veterans and family members, with 454 settlements and awards totaling $98.3 million in 2012 alone.
Those are the reported totals from the government’s own payment data. What no total captures is the machinery this section documents: the review sealed by statute, the disclosure owed and so often missed, and the office — Risk Management — whose work begins where the family’s information ends. The law and directives are collected on the law page; the watchdogs’ findings on the watchdog record; and the tool for starting your own paper trail is Request the File.