The Abbey Gate Thirteen: The Last Americans Killed in Afghanistan, and the Investigation That Missed Its Wounded Witnesses
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Thirteen Americans stood at a gate in Kabul on August 26, 2021, screening people who were trying to escape Afghanistan. Eleven were Marines. One was a Navy hospital corpsman. One was an Army staff sergeant. An ISIS-K bomber reached them through the crowd, and all thirteen were killed. More than 170 Afghans died with them. What followed is also part of the record: an official investigation completed without interviewing wounded witnesses, an admission three years later that those interviews should have mattered, a supplemental review that changed no finding, a Congressional Gold Medal, an apology from the Speaker of the House — and families still asking who, above the gate itself, will be held accountable.
The service, and the promise
The thirteen were:
- Marine Staff Sgt. Darin T. Hoover
- Marine Sgt. Johanny Rosario Pichardo
- Marine Sgt. Nicole L. Gee
- Marine Cpl. Hunter Lopez
- Marine Cpl. Daegan W. Page
- Marine Cpl. Humberto A. Sanchez
- Marine Lance Cpl. David L. Espinoza
- Marine Lance Cpl. Jared M. Schmitz
- Marine Lance Cpl. Rylee J. McCollum
- Marine Lance Cpl. Dylan R. Merola
- Marine Lance Cpl. Kareem M. Nikoui
- Navy Hospital Corpsman 3rd Class Maxton W. Soviak
- Army Staff Sgt. Ryan C. Knauss
They were serving at Hamid Karzai International Airport during the evacuation of Afghanistan in August 2021. Abbey Gate was one of the airport’s entry points. Their work placed them in direct contact with the crowd: checking people, looking for threats, and helping move evacuees through a gate while the city outside the airport was under Taliban control and the threat of an attack was immediate.
That assignment carried a basic institutional promise. The men and women sent to the gate would be given a mission they could carry out, leaders who remained engaged with the danger in front of them, and — if the worst happened — an investigation that began with the people who had actually been there. The first two parts of that promise remain disputed. The third failed in a way the military itself later acknowledged: the original investigation did not interview wounded service members who had been medically evacuated, including Marine Sgt. Tyler Vargas-Andrews.
The dead were not an abstraction to the institution. They were the last Americans killed in the Afghanistan war’s evacuation, and their names became inseparable from the larger question of how the withdrawal was planned and controlled. But a page about accountability has to begin narrower than the politics of a war. It begins with thirteen service members at a crowded gate, doing close-contact screening work because that was the job in front of them.
What happened
On August 26, 2021, an ISIS-K suicide bomber detonated an explosive device at Abbey Gate. The blast killed the thirteen Americans named above and, by CENTCOM’s later public accounting, more than 170 Afghans. Many more people were wounded.
The Americans were not killed in a distant strike or in a vehicle moving through open ground. They were killed while screening evacuees at the airport perimeter. That fact is central to every later dispute. Their position put them close enough to search and assist people in a dense crowd. It also put them within reach of a bomber who could approach as one more person seeking entry.
The attack came during an evacuation already operating under extraordinary pressure. Thousands of Afghans were trying to reach the airport. U.S. forces had to distinguish evacuees from attackers at close range, in a crowd, at a gate. CENTCOM’s later review described the tactical problem in the language of tradeoffs: the attack, it concluded, was “not preventable at the tactical level without degrading the mission.” That sentence would become the institution’s central answer.
The families and surviving witnesses have never accepted that sentence as the end of the inquiry. Their objection is not only to the conclusion. It is also to how the first investigation reached it. The review that produced the original findings was completed in November 2021, but it did not include interviews with service members wounded in the blast who had already been medically evacuated. Sgt. Tyler Vargas-Andrews was one of them. A wounded Marine who had been at the gate was therefore absent from the first official account of what the Marines at the gate saw and did.
That omission matters because the questions in dispute are eyewitness questions. Had the bomber been identified before the explosion? Was there an opportunity to engage him? Did the force at the gate receive and act on the intelligence available to it? Were leaders present and engaged? A review can answer those questions only if it hears from the people positioned to know. For almost two years, the official record rested on an investigation that had not heard from some of those people.
What the institution did afterward
The original investigation was an Army Regulation 15-6 inquiry conducted for U.S. Central Command. CENTCOM later stated that investigators reviewed thousands of pages of documents and interviewed more than 130 witnesses. The inquiry was completed in November 2021. Its central conclusions were publicly briefed on February 4, 2022: the attack was not preventable at the tactical level, and the leaders at Abbey Gate had been present and engaged.
But the witness list had a hole in it. In a statement issued September 15, 2023, CENTCOM acknowledged that the 15-6 team had been unable to interview service members who were wounded and medically evacuated shortly after the attack. It named the significance plainly: those witnesses had not been available to the original investigators. CENTCOM commander Gen. Michael “Erik” Kurilla directed Lt. Gen. Pat Frank, commander of U.S. Army Central, to conduct a supplemental review and interview the previously unavailable witnesses.
That direction came after public testimony by wounded survivors, including Sgt. Vargas-Andrews. The sequence is documented and difficult to soften. The institution first announced a conclusion. A wounded witness then described his account in public. Only after that did the command order a review specifically intended to hear from him and others like him.
The supplemental team conducted more than 50 additional interviews, including 12 with people who had not been available to the original team. It reviewed more than 1,200 pages of additional documents, intelligence, and imagery. The review was completed on January 16, 2024. CENTCOM released its findings on April 15, 2024.
The supplemental review did not change the original result. Its findings were:
- The attack was “not preventable at the tactical level without degrading the mission.”
- Leaders at Abbey Gate were “present, engaged.”
- The bomber had not been previously identified.
- U.S. forces had no opportunity to engage the bomber before the explosion.
- An earlier “IED test run” was unlikely, although the review could not entirely rule it out.
- Taliban forces used excessive force after the attack.
CENTCOM stated that the supplemental review produced no modification to the 2021 findings.
That is the official finding, and it belongs on this page without alteration. Beside it belongs the families’ position: preventability and accountability remain contested. The official finding answers a narrow question — whether the tactical force at the gate could have stopped this bomber without degrading the evacuation mission. The families’ demand reaches above that narrow frame. They have continued to ask who designed the mission, who accepted its risks, who controlled the witness record the first time, and whether senior decision-makers will ever face consequences for the conditions under which thirteen Americans were ordered to screen a crowd at a single gate.
Congress gave the thirteen its highest civilian honor. The Congressional Gold Medal was presented to their families in the Capitol Rotunda on September 10, 2024. Speaker of the House Mike Johnson addressed the families directly: “We are sorry. The United States government should have done everything to protect our troops. Those fallen and wounded at Abbey Gate deserved our best efforts, and the families who have been left to pick up the pieces continue to deserve transparency, appreciation and recognition.”
The apology and the medal are part of the record. So is the fact that neither changed the military’s finding.
Where it stands now
The official military position remains the position announced in April 2024: the supplemental review was thorough, the additional witnesses were heard, and the original conclusion stands. CENTCOM did not find a tactical failure by the leaders at Abbey Gate sufficient to alter the outcome, and it did not identify an opportunity to stop the bomber.
The families’ position also remains on the record: they continue to demand accountability and transparency. The Gold Medal ceremony did not close the dispute. Speaker Johnson’s own words at that ceremony acknowledged that the families still deserved transparency. A medal can honor the dead; it cannot answer whether the mission that placed them at the gate was sound, whether all available intelligence was used, or whether the first investigation should ever have been completed without the wounded.
There is a narrower institutional lesson that does not depend on resolving the larger argument. An investigation into an attack that wounded its own witnesses should not be treated as complete before those witnesses can be interviewed. CENTCOM’s September 2023 statement and the supplemental review it ordered are admissions, in procedural form, that the first record was incomplete. The supplemental review may have strengthened the institution’s confidence in its conclusion. It did not erase the fact that the conclusion had already been announced without those voices.
That is where the Abbey Gate thirteen stand in the public record: honored by Congress, named in full, and still attached to an unanswered distinction between tactical non-preventability and institutional accountability. The first has been decided by CENTCOM. The second is what the families continue to seek.
The ledger
What was owed
- A complete first investigation — one that included the wounded service members who had been at Abbey Gate before conclusions were announced.
- A direct accounting of whether the bomber could have been identified or stopped, and of the decisions that placed a screening force in a dense crowd at the gate.
- Accountability proportionate to whatever failures the complete record showed, at the tactical level and above it.
What was paid
- Thirteen American lives: eleven Marines, Navy Hospital Corpsman 3rd Class Maxton W. Soviak, and Army Staff Sgt. Ryan C. Knauss, killed on August 26, 2021. More than 170 Afghans were also killed.
- The original CENTCOM investigation, completed in November 2021, based on thousands of pages and more than 130 witness interviews, but without interviews with wounded witnesses who had been medically evacuated.
- CENTCOM’s public acknowledgment on September 15, 2023, that those witnesses had not been interviewed, and its order for a supplemental review.
- A supplemental review completed January 16, 2024, with more than 50 additional interviews and more than 1,200 additional pages reviewed; findings released April 15, 2024, with no modification to the original conclusion.
- The Congressional Gold Medal, presented to the families on September 10, 2024, with Speaker Mike Johnson’s public apology and acknowledgment that the families continued to deserve transparency.
What remains open
- Whether the attack was preventable remains contested: CENTCOM says it was not preventable at the tactical level without degrading the mission; the families continue to dispute that this answers the accountability question.
- No finding in the cited record assigns senior-level accountability for the mission conditions at Abbey Gate.
- The first investigation’s missing witness interviews remain a permanent defect in the sequence, even though a supplemental review later heard from twelve previously unavailable witnesses.
- The families’ demand — transparency and accountability, in Speaker Johnson’s own formulation at the medal ceremony — remains unmet to their satisfaction.