Harriet Tubman: Three Years of Service, Two Hundred Dollars, and a Pension Paid Only as Somebody's Widow
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
In June 1863, Harriet Tubman guided Union gunboats up the Combahee River through waters she had scouted, past torpedoes her intelligence had mapped, and in a single operation more than 700 enslaved people ran to the boats and were carried off free. She had already been, for years, the most famous conductor on the Underground Railroad. She then served the Army for roughly three years as a scout, a spy, and a nurse. The United States paid her, in total, about two hundred dollars. This page is the documented record of what she asked for, for thirty years, and what the government finally paid — and under whose name it agreed to pay it.
The service, and the promise
Harriet Tubman was born enslaved in Dorchester County, Maryland, escaped in 1849, and returned south again and again to lead others out. When the Civil War came, she went to South Carolina — to the Union-held Sea Islands around Port Royal — and put the same skills at the Army’s disposal. Union commanders in the Department of the South used her as a scout and spy: she organized and ran a network of scouts among the enslaved and freed people of the coastal country, people who knew the rivers, the roads, and the Confederate dispositions, and who would talk to her when they would talk to no officer. She also served as a nurse, tending wounded and sick soldiers, Black and white, in the hospitals and camps of the Department.
The culminating operation came on the night of June 1–2, 1863: the Combahee River Raid. Tubman had gathered the intelligence for it — the location of Confederate torpedoes in the river, the points where enslaved families waited. She accompanied the expedition aboard the gunboats, guided it upriver, and, as the plantations along the banks were struck and their stores burned, the enslaved people of the Combahee came down to the water. More than 700 were carried away to freedom in one night. It remains one of the most successful operations of its kind in the war, and she is widely credited as the first woman to lead an armed assault in the Civil War.
She served on, nursing and scouting, for roughly three years in total. She was, in the Army’s accounting, a civilian employee attached to the command — which is to say, she stood outside the muster rolls on which pensions would later depend. The promise made to her was made in person, by the officers who used her: that her service would be recognized and paid. Her affidavit to Congress would later state her claim in her own summary: three years’ services “as nurse and cook in hospitals, and as commander of several men (eight or nine) as scouts during the late war of the Rebellion.”
What happened
The Army’s total payment to Harriet Tubman for those three years was about $200. The House of Representatives’ own history of her claim states it without decoration: “After receiving about $200 for her three years of Civil War service, Harriet Tubman spent the next three decades seeking the additional compensation she deserved.”
She went home to Auburn, New York, to a household that depended on her: her aging parents, whom she had brought out of slavery and supported, and a rotating population of the poor, the sick, and the stranded whom she took in off the road. In 1869 she married Nelson Davis, a veteran of the 8th U.S. Colored Infantry. Her means were her labor and her lecture fees, and for the rest of her life they were not enough; the woman who had never lost a passenger on the Railroad, and never lost a soldier she guided, lived in chronic want, carrying dependents the government would not help her carry.
When Davis died in 1888, Tubman became eligible, under the widening widows’ pension laws, for a pension as a veteran’s widow. By 1892 she was receiving $8 a month — paid to her not for the Combahee, not for the scout network, not for the nursing, but because she had been married to a private soldier. Her own claim — for a pension in her own right, as payment for her own service — she pressed separately, and pressed for roughly thirty years. More than fifty of her Auburn neighbors — the people who watched her take in the destitute on $8 a month — petitioned Congress on her behalf. She submitted her affidavit asking, in the end, for a single payment of $1,800 as the proper compensation for her military service.
Congress had been asked before. As early as 1874, Representatives Clinton D. MacDougall of New York and Gerry W. Hazelton of Wisconsin introduced a bill to pay Tubman a $2,000 lump sum for her services; it failed, as did the efforts that followed it across the 1870s and 1880s, while the household she supported in Auburn grew poorer — in 1873 she was swindled out of borrowed money in a fraudulent gold transaction, a catastrophe for a family living at the margin, and precisely the kind of blow a paid pension would have absorbed. The bills kept being introduced because the service kept being undisputed; they kept failing because the pension system had no roll on which a woman scout could be entered.
Her congressman, Sereno Payne of New York, chairman of the Ways and Means Committee, took up the case. In December 1897 he introduced H.R. 4982, a bill to grant Tubman a pension of $25 a month in her own right — the rate of a surviving soldier. The House Committee on Invalid Pensions called it “a very deserving case.” The House passed it. In the Senate’s Committee on Pensions, the record shows, the members considered only the traditional women’s roles she had filled, rather than the raids and the spycraft — and cut the figure to $20.
What the institution did afterward
On February 28, 1899, President William McKinley signed the amended bill into law. What it did, precisely, is the whole of this case: Congress did not grant Harriet Tubman a pension for her own service. It increased her widow’s pension — the pension she held as Nelson Davis’s widow — from $8 to $20 a month. The title of the act was framed so that she was not granted a second pension; the scouts she commanded, the raid she led, and the network she ran were not the thing being paid. The thing being paid was widowhood, raised to an unusual figure “on account of special circumstances.”
The House’s own historians summarize the transaction in one sentence: “Rather than grant Tubman her own pension for her many services, in 1899 President William McKinley approved an increase to her widow’s pension from $8 to $20 a month.” Her claim in her own right was never granted — not in 1874, when the first bills to pay her were introduced, not in 1899, and not ever.
Tubman collected the $20 a month for the remaining fourteen years of her life, dying in Auburn on March 10, 1913, and was buried with military honors at Fort Hill Cemetery. With the pension and donations she bought land adjoining her home and realized the project of her last years: the Harriet Tubman Home for the Aged, a place for the indigent old people — many of them born enslaved — whom she had been sheltering out of her own pocket for decades. The government that would not pension the scout did nothing to build it. She built it herself, on a widow’s $20 a month, out of the same obligation to the discarded that had governed her whole life.
Where it stands now
Tubman’s fame has long since outrun her file. She is among the most honored Americans of her century; her Auburn home and the Home for the Aged are a National Historical Park. The pension record, though, still says exactly what it said in 1899, and no subsequent act has restated it: the United States compensated Harriet Tubman’s Civil War service by adjusting the amount it paid her as another soldier’s widow. The scout’s pension, the spy’s pension, the nurse’s pension in her own name — the claim she actually filed, supported by her officers’ record and her neighbors’ petition — was never granted in her lifetime or after it.
The arithmetic belongs on the record beside the honors. Three years of service: about $200 paid during the war. A demand, reduced by its own claimant to a modest figure: $1,800, never paid. A remedy, after thirty years of asking: an increase in somebody else’s pension category, from $8 to $20 a month, signed February 28, 1899. The gap between the service and the settlement is not an interpretation. It is the file.
The ledger
What has been done
- February 28, 1899 — President McKinley signed the act raising Tubman’s pension from $8 to $20 a month.
- She was buried with military honors at Fort Hill Cemetery, Auburn, in 1913, and her home and the Home for the Aged she founded are now preserved as a National Historical Park.
What has not been done
- A pension in her own right — for her service as scout, spy, and nurse — was never granted, in the thirty years she sought it or since.
- The $1,800 she claimed as proper compensation for her own service was never paid.
- The about $200 she received during the war stands as the Army’s total direct payment for three years that included the Combahee River Raid.
What is being sought
- The claim is closed by time; no living petitioner remains. What remains is the record’s accuracy: that when the roll of her honors is read, the pension file be read with it — $200 for the service, and the remedy paid under her husband’s name.
Sources
- U.S. House of Representatives, History, Art & Archives, “The ‘Very Deserving Case’ of Harriet Tubman” (Whereas blog), March 30, 2021 — about $200 for three years of service; three decades of petitioning; the Auburn neighbors’ petitions; H.R. 4982 at $25 a month; the Senate reduction; McKinley’s signature on February 28, 1899, raising the widow’s pension from $8 to $20: https://history.house.gov/Blog/2021/March/3-30-Tubman/
- U.S. House of Representatives, History, Art & Archives, “Harriet Tubman’s Pension Claim” — her affidavit requesting $1,800 for “three years services as nurse and cook in hospitals, and as commander of several men (eight or nine) as scouts,” and the disposition: “Rather than grant Tubman her own pension for her many services, in 1899 President William McKinley approved an increase to her widow’s pension from $8 to $20 a month”: https://history.house.gov/HouseRecord/Detail/25769819744
- National Park Service, Harriet Tubman Home / Harriet Tubman National Historical Park, Auburn, New York — her South Carolina service, the dependents she supported, and the Home for the Aged she founded for the indigent elderly: https://www.nps.gov/hart/
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.