IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

John Toombs: The Sergeant Expelled From Treatment Who Died on the VA's Own Grounds

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

John Toombs asked the Department of Veterans Affairs for help, and he said so himself, on camera, in the last hours of his life. He was a sergeant who had served in Afghanistan, a patient in the VA's own residential treatment program in Murfreesboro, Tennessee, and on the morning of November 22, 2016, that program expelled him for being late to his medication. He never left the campus. Sometime before dawn, after recording a final video on his phone, he hanged himself at a construction site on the grounds of the Alvin C. York VA campus — the institution that was treating him. This page is the documented record: what the program did, what his father, David Toombs, says happened that night and what the VA denies, who was and was not disciplined afterward, and what his father has sought since.

The service, and the promise

John Toombs IV was from Murfreesboro, Tennessee. He served one tour in Afghanistan, left the Army as a sergeant, and came home, in NPR’s reporting, with what the VA itself later concluded was probably post-traumatic stress disorder — and, soon after, a drug problem. After the Army, he worked beside his father, David Toombs, at a steel die shop in Murfreesboro. His father made his lunch every morning, and made extra, in case his son was hungry or running low on money — “like a typical dad,” David Toombs said.

The promise made to a veteran in John Toombs’s position is the central promise of the VA system itself: come in, ask for help, and the institution built for that purpose will treat you. He did come in. The drug problem that followed his service landed him in the residential treatment program at the Murfreesboro VA — the Alvin C. York campus — for addiction treatment, alongside treatment for PTSD. It was, by design, the place where a veteran in his condition was supposed to be safest: living on the grounds, under supervision, inside an intensive therapeutic program. NPR described that program plainly: it was meant to be an intensive therapeutic atmosphere, but it also demanded strict discipline. A residential patient is not an outpatient who can be sent home to a stable life between appointments; he is a person the institution has taken in precisely because his condition requires structure, supervision, and continuity of care.

The facility he entered had no strong record to fall back on. Murfreesboro was then one of the lowest-rated VA medical centers in the country. The VA’s 2016 Quality of Care report, as Air Force Times summarized it, ranked the center among the lowest in the entire VA system for its mental-health care. In the VA’s own internal rating system, Murfreesboro was part of a triangle of three Tennessee centers — Nashville, Memphis, and Murfreesboro — that each held one star out of a possible five.

What happened

On the morning of November 22, 2016, John Toombs was, in NPR’s word, abruptly kicked out of the residential program. The reason documented in every account is the same: he was late to take his medication. Air Force Times, reporting the Washington Post’s investigation in February 2019, gave the measure of the lateness: 20 minutes late to pick up his medications, and expelled also, that account said, for not following the program’s instructions. A 32-year-old veteran in residential treatment for addiction and PTSD was removed from that treatment, that morning, over a medication line he reached 20 minutes late.

Later that day, his father came to pick him up. David Toombs recalled the exchange for NPR: “I said, ‘Come on John, let’s go, I don’t want to leave you out here.’” His son did not want to leave. John Toombs told his father what he intended to do instead, and his father’s account of it is part of the documented record: “He said, ‘I’m gonna be OK. I’m gonna sleep in the emergency room, go see the patients’ advocate and the director in the morning, and try to get back in the program.’”

By his father’s account, the expelled patient did not plan to disappear. He planned to stay at the VA, sleep in its emergency room, and in the morning go to the patient advocate and the director — the institution’s own channels — to ask to be readmitted. He remained on campus all day and all night.

What happened in the emergency room that night is contested, and this page prints both accounts, labeled, because the sources do.

The father’s account: David Toombs believes his son went to the emergency room that night and was turned away.

The VA’s account: The Department of Veterans Affairs denies that account — NPR reported the denial in the same sentence as the father’s belief.

The sources opened for this page do not resolve that conflict, and this page does not resolve it either. What is not contested is the sequence around it: expelled in the morning, on the campus through the day and the night, intending — by his father’s account — to seek readmission in the morning.

Sometime before dawn — overnight, November 22–23, 2016 — John Toombs recorded a video on his phone. It is the last statement in the record, and it is his:

“When I asked for help, they opened up a Pandora’s box inside of me and just kicked me out the door. That’s how they treat veterans around here.”

The video was not only an accusation. In the same message, NPR reported, he thanked the people who did help him. “Some of you I love more than the whole wide world,” he said, and the message ends.

Then he went to a construction site on the VA campus and hanged himself. He was 32 years old. He died on the grounds of the institution he had entered for treatment, before the morning on which — by his father’s account — he had meant to ask its director to take him back. It was, as Air Force Times stated it, just before Thanksgiving 2016. His father kept his son’s suicide note. And he went on the record, by name, and he sued.

What the institution did afterward

The Murfreesboro center’s leadership, at the time of John Toombs’s death, was itself new. Jennifer Vedral-Baron, a former Navy captain who had previously run U.S. military hospitals, had been sent by the VA to Tennessee in 2016 to turn the Nashville and Murfreesboro centers around. She was, NPR reported, only three months on the job when John Toombs took his life. “My heart continues to go out for this family. I did meet with the family not long after Sgt. Toombs’ death. We cried together, we talked about the future,” she said. David Toombs said the meeting made an impression on him as well: “I can honestly say that I have the highest regards for her. She was a Navy captain. She could only say what she was allowed to say. But she really, really was emotional about it.”

Under Vedral-Baron, the centers’ ratings rose, by her account, from one star to two stars. She said she had fired 47 staff members, moved many others into different posts, and hired a former Army doctor who had served in Iraq, Dr. John Jackson, to oversee mental health care. Jackson had not been working at Murfreesboro when John Toombs died.

The accountability record specific to John Toombs’s program is narrower. Since the suicide, all the senior staff at the residential program had left or been reassigned. But the only person who was fired from the program was a nurse, Rosalinde Burch. And Burch, NPR reported, said in an affidavit that she was fired for speaking out about the mistreatment of John Toombs. Vedral-Baron said she could not comment on Burch’s firing because of privacy concerns. The distinction is exact: the 47 firings were across the centers she directed; within the program that expelled John Toombs, the single termination NPR documented was of the nurse who said she had spoken out about how he was treated. No source opened for this page documents the firing of anyone who made or carried out the decision to expel him.

David Toombs’s own position, stated to NPR, was not abolition but accountability. He wanted the people responsible for kicking his son out to lose their jobs, and in the same account said he did not hate the VA: “As far as saying I’m anti-VA? We don’t need shut it down; no, we need to fix it.” His judgment on his son’s death was just as plain: “My son died because of their arrogance and negligence.” If the lawsuit succeeded, he said, he would use the money to fund a scholarship and other veterans’ causes.

Where it stands now

Two formal proceedings carry this case in the documented record: a lawsuit, and a bill.

The lawsuit. David Toombs sued the VA for $2 million. The claim, as NPR reported it, is that staff callously kicked his son out and did not follow the VA’s own rules to make sure he was safe and stable. The suit further claimed that the director of the program was making an example out of John and should have known he was a high risk for suicide. In its court documents, NPR reported, the VA denies that. Vedral-Baron said she could not discuss the lawsuit. The sources opened for this page, running through February 2019, do not record an outcome: the father’s claim and the VA’s denial both stand, unresolved in the sources.

The naming. At the meeting with the family after the death, it was Vedral-Baron herself who brought up naming the new building — at the construction site where John Toombs died — the “Sgt. John Toombs Residential Rehabilitation Treatment Facility.” David Toombs supported the idea. It moved into Congress as a bill, which NPR noted in August 2018 might become law that fall; Vedral-Baron said she remained in favor of it even though it made some VA staff uncomfortable, and hoped it would help destigmatize suicide and mental-health care. David Toombs, driving past the campus, called the unfinished building “my son’s building.” The sources opened for this page do not record the bill’s final enactment: the director proposed the name, the father backed it, and Congress took it up — while the same father was suing the same department for $2 million over the same death.

The national record. In February 2019, Air Force Times reported the Washington Post’s investigation into veterans dying by suicide on VA campuses, and John Toombs’s case was one of the cases it featured. The figures frame his death as part of a documented pattern, not an isolated event: 19 suicides occurred on VA campuses from October 2017 to November 2018, seven of them in parking lots, according to data the Post obtained from the VA; the VA said it had prevented 233 suicide attempts in that same window. There were more than 6,000 reported veteran suicides every year from 2008 to 2016, and as of 2016 the veteran suicide rate was 1.5 times higher than for non-veteran adults. His death, in November 2016, predates that count; the later reporting reached back for his case because the sequence it documented was the sequence the nation was still counting.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what has been done, what has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door