Peter Antioho: The Captain Whose Claim Was Approved Only After a Senator Intervened
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Peter Antioho was a West Point graduate and an Army captain who was exposed to toxic burn pits in Afghanistan in 2012. In February 2018 he was diagnosed with grade 4 glioblastoma — terminal brain cancer. What followed, in his widow's summary, was a division of his remaining life into two fights: "We spent the first year fighting the disease and the second year fighting VA." The Department of Veterans Affairs twice rejected his claims, on the stated ground that the burden was on him to prove the burn pits caused his cancer. Approval came in 2019, only after a United States senator's office intervened, a little over a year before he died on September 27, 2020. His own verdict on that process, relayed by Sen. Richard Blumenthal, is the sentence this page exists to record: no veteran should have to call a U.S. Senator to get what they deserve.
The service, and the promise
Peter Antioho, of Berlin, Connecticut, was a graduate of the United States Military Academy at West Point and an officer in the United States Army. Friends described him to Military.com as a military “lifer” — a man whose plans ran forward through the Army, including, his widow Amy recalled, an intention to go into special operations.
He deployed to Afghanistan in 2012, where, the Senate record states, he was exposed to toxic burn pits. The exposure was not abstract to him. Amy Antioho remembered his own assessment of it, delivered while he was still well enough to make it: “I just remember him saying the burn pit was going to kill him someday.”
The promise to an officer like Peter Antioho is the same one made to every service member, and it does not contain an asterisk for illnesses that take years to appear: serve where you are sent, breathe what you are given to breathe, and if it wounds you, the country will carry the cost. Glioblastoma is a wound that arrives on a delay. The record of his case is the record of what the institution did with that delay — it used it, for two years, as a reason to say no.
What happened
Looking back, Amy Antioho told Military.com and Public Health Watch, she believed a malignancy may have been taking root in Peter’s brain well before anyone named it. During the last year of his military service, she watched changes she could not then explain: he inexplicably abandoned his plans to go into special operations, then decided to leave the Army altogether — despite having no job and a pregnant wife. He began taking risks, acting impulsively, and became extremely paranoid, a symptom, the reporting notes, for some with brain cancer. An early diagnosis, Amy said, would not have changed the outcome. It would have eased the VA claims process, and given the couple back some time.
In February 2018, Peter Antioho was diagnosed with glioblastoma multiforme — a grade 4 brain tumor, terminal brain cancer. Glioblastoma’s average life expectancy, in the general population it usually strikes in people’s sixties, runs twelve to eighteen months. The Antiohos’ son, Mark, was a small child; he was five years old when Military.com published its investigation in January 2022, and he has come to know his father, his mother said, through notes from friends and family recollections.
Peter’s last days were spent in hospice. Amy remembered having to shelter him from nurses who kept telling him he would eventually get better and go home. She remembered lying next to him, listening to the soundtrack of Les Misérables, holding him as Marius cradles a dying Éponine in the story. She relived, for the reporters, the moment she gave him permission to go — trying to free him from the responsibility of caring for his family.
Peter Antioho died of glioblastoma on September 27, 2020.
The disease that killed him was not rare among the men and women who served where he served. Among post-9/11 veterans who deployed to Iraq, Afghanistan, and elsewhere, glioblastoma occurs at a rate 26% higher than in the general population, according to calculations based on Department of Veterans Affairs and National Institutes of Health data reported by Military.com. And most of the stricken veterans and their families, that investigation found, believed their illnesses were caused by military environmental exposures — the belching pits of burning trash, the jet fuel, the plastics, the chemicals in the air of the bases where they lived.
What the institution did afterward
The VA’s system, as it stood when Peter Antioho filed, drew a bright line — and he was on the wrong side of it. The VA automatically grants benefits to service members diagnosed with brain cancer on active duty, to veterans who worked with radiation while serving, and to those who develop the disease within a year of discharge. Everyone else must file a disability compensation claim and prove the connection themselves.
Peter Antioho filed. The VA twice rejected his claims for disability benefits, in Sen. Blumenthal’s summary, “arguing the burden was on him to prove the cancer was caused by the burn pits.”
Amy Antioho described the cycle to Military.com: “I was learning as I went. Give them evidence, get denied. Give them evidence, get denied. Each time I thought it would go through because I had all my ducks in a row. And again, denied.” The Antiohos fought the claims battle with help from the Connecticut Veterans Legal Center, and Amy Antioho has said plainly that the process should not be so complicated — involving VA claims officers, veterans service organizations, lawmakers, and sometimes lawyers — for a family spending the same months on a terminal diagnosis.
His claim was approved in 2019, Blumenthal’s office records, only following assistance from the senator’s office — a little over a year before Peter died. The approval was real, and it mattered, and it arrived by a route that is not in any regulation: a widow’s persistence, a legal aid organization’s help, press attention, and a United States senator’s intervention. Peter’s own conclusion from the experience is the one Blumenthal carried into the record at the White House: “no veteran should have to call a United States Senator to get what they deserve.”
The Antioho case was not an outlier in the system that produced it, and the numbers require care, because the VA gave two versions of them. Military.com and Public Health Watch reported that 42% of the 2,126 post-9/11 veterans who had developed brain cancer had been denied access to health care and disability compensation by the VA. The VA told the reporters on November 5, 2021, that the claims approval rate was just 16.7% for post-9/11 veterans with brain cancer, while it was over 70% and 80%, respectively, for Vietnam and Persian Gulf War era veterans. Then, days before publication, the VA revised its own data: the approval rate for post-9/11 veterans was, it said, much higher — 58% — and the Gulf War era rate much lower, at 31%. Officials said the 16.7% figure had been produced using a “dated system,” and that a new algorithm sorted veterans into their periods of service more accurately. Either way, the investigation’s bottom line stood: just about half of the veterans who had served since August 1990 and developed brain cancer had had their claims denied.
The scientific record, as the VA’s defenders framed it, was genuinely incomplete — and this page records that too, because the family’s argument was never that the studies existed. Army Lt. Col. Brett Theeler, a neuro-oncologist at the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, told the reporters it is hard to draw a definitive link between battlefield exposures and brain cancer because the research is scant: “Those studies just don’t exist in brain cancer that link it to a modern environmental exposure. Doesn’t mean there isn’t a link. There’s just never been a study that has been able to show it.” The question Peter Antioho’s case posed to the institution was who should bear the cost of that missing research: the government that burned the pits, or the captain dying with a small child at home. For two years, the VA’s answer was the captain.
Where it stands now
On August 10, 2022, Amy and Mark Antioho stood in the White House with Sen. Blumenthal for the signing of the Sergeant First Class Heath Robinson Honoring Our Promise to Address Comprehensive Toxics Act — the PACT Act. Amy had promised Peter, Blumenthal said, that they would get it across the finish line, and she and the families of veterans did it.
The law changed the rule that had governed Peter’s claim. Glioblastoma is now among the conditions the PACT Act lists as presumptive for veterans exposed to burn pits and other toxic substances in the Gulf War and post-9/11 eras: the VA presumes the service connection it once made Peter Antioho prove. The law, Blumenthal’s office said, would “correct the nearly 80 percent rejection rate faced by burn pit veterans seeking claims.”
Blumenthal stated the causation question as the family’s advocate, in words this page attributes to him: “We lost Peter Antioho to glioblastoma, a hideous form of cancer that was caused by these burn pits. I came to know him and his family and advocate for him when he needed care and benefits, but one thing he said to us is… no veteran should have to call a United States Senator to get what they deserve. He was right, and he was a big part of the inspiration.”
Amy Antioho’s message at the signing was addressed to the families still inside the process her family had survived: “My message to all the veterans and families still fighting is don’t give up. Please don’t give up or take no for an answer. Please apply for benefits.” She described meeting Heath Robinson’s widow and young daughter, and her son and the Robinson girl fist-bumping: “‘Your daddy died too? So did my daddy.’ And I think that’s what people need to realize, is that these are real human beings with families, with children that will grow up without fathers and mothers and siblings… The cost of war is too high and it comes home with us.”
Peter Antioho did not live to see the presumption his case argued for. He died on September 27, 2020, nearly two years before the law was signed — with his claim approved, in the end, through the one channel his own sentence condemns.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- Peter Antioho’s claim was approved in 2019, after two rejections — following assistance from Sen. Blumenthal’s office, with the Connecticut Veterans Legal Center’s help in the fight.
- The PACT Act was signed on August 10, 2022, with Amy and Mark Antioho present. Glioblastoma is now a presumptive condition for burn pit–exposed veterans, ending the prove-it-yourself burden that governed his claim.
What has not been done
- The approval came a little over a year before his death, and only through senatorial intervention. Nothing in the record shows the VA revisiting, on its own, why a claim it ultimately granted was twice denied while the claimant was dying.
- The VA’s own accounting of how many like him it turned away remains unsettled on the record: the department first reported a 16.7% approval rate for post-9/11 brain-cancer claims, then revised it to 58% days before the investigation published, attributing the first figure to a “dated system.”
What is being sought
- The standard Peter Antioho himself stated, carried into the record by Sen. Blumenthal: that no veteran should have to call a United States Senator to get what they deserve — and Amy Antioho’s standing instruction to the families still filing: don’t give up, and don’t take no for an answer.
Sources
- U.S. Senator Richard Blumenthal, “Senator Blumenthal Week In Review 08/05/2022—08/12/2022” — the White House PACT Act signing with Amy and Mark Antioho, the 2012 Afghanistan burn pit exposure, the grade 4 diagnosis, the VA’s two rejections and burden-of-proof position, the 2019 approval after his office’s assistance, and Peter Antioho’s statement that no veteran should have to call a Senator: https://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/senator-blumenthal-week-in-review-08/05/202208/12/2022
- U.S. Senator Richard Blumenthal, “Blumenthal & Family of CT Veteran Attend President Biden’s Signing of Landmark Burn Pit Legislation,” August 10, 2022 — the signing ceremony, Blumenthal’s and Amy Antioho’s full statements, and the PACT Act’s correction of the burn pit claims rejection rate: https://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/newsroom/press/release/blumenthal-and-family-of-ct-veteran-attend-president-bidens-signing-of-landmark-burn-pit-legislation
- Military.com and Public Health Watch, “Young and Dying: Veterans Are Getting Brain Cancer and Struggling to Get Benefits,” January 11, 2022 — Amy Antioho’s account (“We spent the first year fighting the disease and the second year fighting VA”), Peter’s death on September 27, 2020, the 16.7% approval figure VA first reported and its pre-publication revision to 58%, the 26% higher glioblastoma rate among post-9/11 veterans, and the state of the science: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2022/01/11/young-and-dying-veterans-are-getting-brain-cancer-and-struggling-get-benefits.html
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed. Videos are embedded from their publishers; nothing here is re-hosted.