Andrew Jackson Smith: The Medal That Took 137 Years
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
On November 30, 1864, in the fight for a twenty-five-foot rise called Honey Hill, the color bearer of the 55th Massachusetts Infantry was killed carrying the regimental colors into grape and canister fire. Corporal Andrew Jackson Smith — a man born enslaved in Kentucky — took the colors from the dead man's hands and carried them through the rest of the battle. His colonel recommended him for the Medal of Honor. The medal was awarded on January 16, 2001: one hundred thirty-seven years after the battle, sixty-nine years after Smith's death, in a ceremony where the President of the United States said, on the record, that the Army's reason for refusing it had been wrong. This page is the documented record.
The service, and the promise
Andrew Jackson Smith was born on September 3, 1843, in Lyon County, Kentucky, enslaved — the son of Susan, an enslaved woman, and Elijah Smith, her owner. When the Civil War came he was taken into Confederate country as a servant and, in the confusion of the Kentucky campaigns, escaped to Union lines and attached himself to the 41st Illinois Infantry, serving as an officer’s servant — with Major Lawrence T. Warner — through Fort Donelson and Shiloh, where he was present under fire without a musket or a status. Warner, wounded at Shiloh, took Smith home with him to Clinton, Illinois, on furlough — an extraordinary arrangement that says much about both men — and when Smith heard that President Lincoln was authorizing Black regiments, Warner gave him the money for the journey east to enlist as a soldier in his own right.
On May 16, 1863, he was mustered into Company B, 55th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry — the sister regiment of the famous 54th — as a private. He served in the coastal operations in South Carolina and Florida, was promoted to corporal, and was assigned to the color guard, the small party of men whose duty was to carry and defend the regiment’s flags: the national colors and the state colors that marked the regiment’s position, rallied its line, and whose loss in battle was a regiment’s disgrace.
At Honey Hill, South Carolina, on November 30, 1864, the 55th and 54th Massachusetts were thrown against entrenched Confederate positions. In the words of Smith’s Medal of Honor citation, during the charge the color bearer was shot and killed; Smith retrieved and saved both the state and federal flags, carrying them through heavy grape and canister fire for the remainder of the fight. He was wounded in the war’s service and mustered out with the regiment in 1865. His commanding officer, Colonel Alfred Hartwell, recommended him for the Medal of Honor almost immediately after the battle. The recommendation entered the Army’s machinery, and there, for half a century, it rested.
What happened
Smith lived the unrecorded life of a Black veteran in the decades after Appomattox: he lived out his days near Grand Rivers, Kentucky, a leader in his community, raising his family — the family whose keeping of his papers across four generations is the reason this page can be written. His daughters preserved the family’s record of the Honey Hill story as a matter of inheritance, the way other families preserve land.
The case revived in 1916, when Dr. Burt G. Wilder, who had been the 55th Massachusetts’ regimental surgeon and had maintained a lifelong correspondence with Smith, formally nominated him for the Medal of Honor — the same medal Hartwell had recommended in 1864. The nomination went in during December 1916. The Army considered it for roughly two weeks — the American Battlefield Trust’s account calls what the War Department performed “a meager two weeks of research” — and in January 1917 it was denied. The Army’s stated ground was that there were no official records to prove his story and his acts of courage — that the documentation did not exist.
The claim was erroneous, and that word is not this site’s; it is the word of a President of the United States, speaking in the Roosevelt Room in 2001: the Army “claimed, erroneously, that there were no official records to prove his story.” The records existed. They were found, when the family went looking, in the National Archives, where they had been since the end of the Civil War — the same government’s archive, holding the same government’s papers, unconsulted or unacknowledged by the same government’s reviewers in 1917. Smith lived fifteen more years after the denial and died on March 4, 1932, aged eighty-eight, the medal unissued, the official reason on file being that his battle had left no trace.
What the institution did afterward
The institution did nothing further for sixty-nine years. The correction was made by the family, using the papers the family and the archive between them had kept.
Smith’s grandson, Andrew (Smith) Bowman, took up the case — determined, in the family’s phrase, that his grandfather would receive his medal — and spent years in the research and the lobbying: assembling the record from the National Archives, working with historians Sharon MacDonald and Rob Beckman, and pressing the case through the channels that a posthumous correction requires. His aunt — Smith’s daughter Caruth Smith Washington — had herself saved paperwork dating back to the nineteenth century documenting her father’s bravery; the family’s archive and the nation’s archive, laid side by side, made the case the Army had said could not be made. In 2000, Congress passed legislation removing the statutory time limit that stood in the way of the award.
On January 16, 2001, in the Roosevelt Room of the White House, President Bill Clinton presented the Medal of Honor for Corporal Andrew Jackson Smith. He presented it to the soldier’s ninety-three-year-old daughter, Caruth Smith Washington, and to his grandson Andrew Bowman — with eight members of the family present. Clinton told the story in the open, including the 1916 nomination and the Army’s erroneous claim, and the citation was read: “Corporal Andrew Jackson Smith, of Clinton, Illinois, a member of the 55th Massachusetts Voluntary Infantry, distinguished himself on 30 November 1864 by saving his regimental colors, after the color bearer was killed during a bloody charge called the Battle of Honey Hill, South Carolina.”
Smith’s was the last Medal of Honor awarded to a Black Civil War soldier — the final entry in a roll the Army had left open since 1865 for want, it said in 1917, of paperwork it was already holding. The medal is now displayed at the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum in Springfield, Illinois. The 55th Massachusetts’ regimental colors — the flags themselves — are preserved at the Concord Museum in Concord, Massachusetts.
Where it stands now
The award of January 16, 2001 holds the record this site knows best how to state: it was, at the time, the most delayed award of a medal in the nation’s history — 137 years from act to medal. Nothing about the delay was evidentiary by the end. The 1917 reviewers did not find the record wanting; they reported, wrongly, that there was no record. The papers that refuted them had never left the government’s own custody.
What closed the gap was not a new policy or an institutional audit of old denials. It was a family that treated a grandfather’s entitlement as a trust: daughters who kept the papers, a grandson who spent years in the archives and the corridors, and a ninety-three-year-old woman who outlived the denial by eighty-four years and stood in the Roosevelt Room to accept her father’s medal. It is worth recording what the family was carrying it against: not an absence of evidence, but an official finding, renewed by silence for eight decades, that the evidence did not exist — a finding any clerk could have falsified in an afternoon in the government’s own archive, at any time between 1917 and 2001, had the institution ever assigned one to look. No one was assigned. The family assigned itself. Andrew Jackson Smith carried the colors through one afternoon of canister fire at Honey Hill. His family carried his case through the rest of the twentieth century. The second carry took longer, and only one of the two was ever in doubt.
The ledger
What has been done
- January 16, 2001 — the Medal of Honor was awarded to Corporal Andrew Jackson Smith, presented by President Clinton to his daughter Caruth Smith Washington, aged 93, and his grandson Andrew Bowman, with eight family members present.
- Congress in 2000 removed the statutory time limit that had barred the award.
- The medal is displayed at the Abraham Lincoln Presidential Library and Museum; the regimental colors are preserved at the Concord Museum.
What has not been done
- The medal did not come in Smith’s lifetime: nominated by his colonel in 1864 and again by his regimental surgeon in 1916, it was denied in January 1917 on the Army’s erroneous claim that no official records existed — records that had sat in the National Archives since the Civil War.
- He died on March 4, 1932, with the denial standing; the correction took a further sixty-nine years and was carried entirely by his descendants.
What is being sought
- The case is closed, and closed correctly. What remains is the record’s lesson, in the President’s own word for the 1917 ground: erroneously. The archive had the truth the whole time. The family had to go and get it.
Sources
- William J. Clinton, “Remarks by the President at Medal of Honor Ceremony,” The Roosevelt Room, January 16, 2001 — the Honey Hill account, the 1916 nomination, the Army’s erroneous claim that no official records existed, Smith’s death in 1932, and the presentation to Andrew Bowman and Caruth Smith Washington, “a very young 93,” with eight family members present: https://clintonwhitehouse5.archives.gov/textonly/library/hot_releases/January_16_2001_4.html
- Emerging Civil War, February 12, 2018 — Smith’s muster into Company B, 55th Massachusetts, on May 16, 1863; the Honey Hill color rescue; Colonel Alfred Hartwell’s recommendation at the time; the records found in the National Archives; and the grandson’s campaign: https://emergingcivilwar.com/2018/02/12/not-the-same-african-americans-we-always-see/
- American Battlefield Trust, “Better Late Than Never” — the 1916 nomination by the regiment’s surgeon, the January 1917 denial after two weeks of research, the daughter who preserved the legacy and the grandson who carried it, and the 2000 act of Congress that cleared the time limit: https://www.battlefields.org/learn/articles/head-tilting-history/better-late-never
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.