Logan Melgar: The Green Beret Killed by His Own Team in Mali
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Logan Melgar was thirty-four years old, a staff sergeant in the Green Berets, asleep in his room in Bamako, Mali, when four fellow American special operators broke down his door with a sledgehammer shortly before 5 a.m. on June 4, 2017. Minutes later he was dead by asphyxiation. His family was first told he had died of illness, and then that he had died in a training accident. Neither was true. This page is the documented record of what happened, what the courts-martial established, and what the sentences were — told in dates, charges, and pleas.
The service, and the promise
Logan J. Melgar was raised in Lubbock, Texas. He enlisted in the U.S. Army in January 2012 as a Special Forces candidate and began Special Forces training in 2013. He became a Special Forces engineer sergeant and was assigned to 2nd Battalion, 3rd Special Forces Group (Airborne). He completed two deployments to Afghanistan as an engineer sergeant. His military education, recorded by the Green Beret Foundation, included Basic Airborne School, the Special Forces Qualification Course, Survival, Evasion, Resistance and Escape School, the Special Forces Advanced Reconnaissance Target Exploitation Course, Sniper Course, and the Advanced Leader Course.
In 2017 he was deployed to Bamako, the capital of Mali, as part of a small team supporting the U.S. Embassy and counterterrorism operations in the region. He shared off-site embassy housing with other special operators, including two members of Naval Special Warfare Development Group — DEVGRU, known as SEAL Team Six. He was nearing the end of that deployment when he died.
He was survived by his wife of ten years, Michelle Melgar, and their two sons, Jackson and Tyler.
The promise made to a soldier in that housing is the most basic one in the profession: the men in the next rooms are your team. A soldier asleep in his own quarters, in housing provided by his own government, is supposed to be safe. The record that follows is the record of four men from America’s most elite units breaking that promise in a planned attack, and of the explanations given for it afterward — explanations that have never been reconciled with each other.
What happened
On the night of June 3 into the early morning of June 4, 2017, two Navy SEALs — Chief Petty Officers Anthony E. DeDolph and Adam C. Matthews of DEVGRU — and two Marine Raiders — Gunnery Sgt. Mario Madera-Rodriguez and Staff Sgt. Kevin Maxwell Jr. — planned an assault on Melgar while drinking at two local bars, Appaloosa and Byblos, according to statements provided to investigators and later testimony. The Raiders went to their separate residence to get duct tape and a sledgehammer.
The plan, as Matthews and Maxwell later testified, was to break into Melgar’s room, choke him unconscious, bind him with duct tape, and record a staged sexual assault to humiliate him. Maxwell’s statement, reported by The Washington Post and cited in court reporting, said the four planned to have a Malian man who was present sexually assault a bound Melgar while a British man filmed the episode. Testimony and reports indicated six to seven individuals were present or involved in some capacity, including the two SEALs, the two Raiders, an unnamed British service member, and one or two Malian security guards. Only the four Americans were charged.
At about 5 a.m. the group used the sledgehammer to break open Melgar’s door. He woke immediately. DeDolph, a former professional mixed martial arts fighter, pounced on him and put him in a chokehold while the others secured his arms and legs and began to duct-tape him. Melgar stopped breathing. The men removed the tape, attempted to revive him, performed CPR and a field tracheotomy, and took him to a nearby clinic, where he was pronounced dead. His cause of death was asphyxiation.
What he was attacked for is contested, and this page presents the two accounts as the record presents them — labeled, and not reconciled.
The hazing account, as given by the defendants. Matthews testified that the four planned the assault in retaliation for perceived personal slights by Melgar during the deployment. In the defendants’ account, a perceived party snub was the last straw: Melgar had been invited to an embassy party, the others had not, and, in the version summarized on the record, he had abandoned or driven past them en route to an event in a city prone to terrorist activity. Their stated intent, in that account, was to teach him a lesson by filming him in a compromising sexual situation — not to kill him. DeDolph’s attorney later said his client “never intended to injure” Melgar.
The silencing account, as reported from investigators and other operators. A different account was reported as early as November 2017. Five members of the special-operations community, speaking to The Daily Beast and cited in Military Times reporting, alleged that Melgar had discovered the SEALs and Raiders stealing funds intended for paying local informants, that the money was used among other things to hire prostitutes and purchase diamonds, that Melgar was offered a share of the money and refused it, and that the planned filmed assault was intended to blackmail him into silence. Shortly before his death, Melgar had emailed his wife that he had a “bad feeling” about some of the troops he was working with; Michelle Melgar shared those emails with investigators. All four defendants denied the theft and silencing accusations. No court-martial in this case convicted any defendant of theft, and the motive was never settled by a verdict.
Those are the two accounts on the public record. The courts-martial established the assault, the chokehold, the binding, and the planned filming. They did not establish, as a finding, why it was done.
What the institution did afterward
The first accounts given to the family were false, and they came in sequence.
When a chaplain and an Army officer came to Michelle Melgar’s door, she was told Logan had been sick — that he had been found convulsing in bed. She told them, in her later courtroom account, “You’re lying to me.” She had spoken with him only hours before; he was fine, and he had not been sick. After the sickness explanation passed, she was told he had died while doing combatives, or self-defense training, with the SEALs in their residence. “I just wanted the truth,” she said. “I knew he wasn’t sick. I knew he wasn’t doing combatives at 5 in the morning.”
The explanations given to investigators followed the same pattern. The SEALs first told investigators they had been practicing hand-to-hand combat in the residence, that Melgar was drunk, and that no one else was involved. Toxicology found no alcohol or drugs in Melgar’s system. The story fell apart, in the court reporting, as the autopsy findings and other accounts placed the Raiders in the room as well. Investigators also noted injury to Melgar’s throat; the defendants said they had attempted an emergency tracheotomy after finding him unconscious. Sources alleged to investigators that the tracheotomy was performed long after his death, as part of a cover story.
The Naval Criminal Investigative Service identified the two SEAL Team Six members as persons of interest shortly after the death. They were removed from Mali and placed on administrative leave. Jurisdiction passed from the Army to the Navy in September 2017. By February 2018 the investigation had expanded to a comprehensive internal military audit of SEAL Team Six, focused on the SEALs’ conflicting accounts, and the two Marine Raiders were implicated as accomplices. The Pentagon released no information about the death at the time; news outlets broke the story months later, in the fall of 2017.
In November 2018 — seventeen months after the death — four men were charged with felony murder, involuntary manslaughter, burglary, conspiracy to commit assault and battery, obstruction of justice, making false statements, and hazing:
- Navy SEALs from DEVGRU: Chief Petty Officers Anthony E. DeDolph and Adam C. Matthews.
- Marine Raiders: Gunnery Sgt. Mario Madera-Rodriguez and Staff Sgt. Kevin Maxwell Jr.
Matthews and Maxwell testified that DeDolph was the ringleader who got the others to agree to choke Melgar unconscious and bind him with duct tape.
One further episode belongs in this section, because it happened while those charges were pending. In January 2019, Matthews encountered Michelle Melgar at a Las Vegas party. According to documents obtained by The Washington Post, he approached the widow under a pseudonym, trying to learn more about what she knew regarding her husband’s death and the SEAL’s involvement. The fuller account carried in the case record is that, using a fake name, he flirted, danced with her, exchanged numbers, and asked to accompany her to her room; she declined; and before that, he told her the men who killed her husband were “good guys.” Matthews’ attorney, Grover Baxley, acknowledged to the Post that the incident had occurred, but stressed there was no romantic involvement and the meeting was “unintentional.” Michelle Melgar’s statement at Matthews’ May 2019 hearing — in which she thanked him for “finally coming forward with some of the truth” — was made before the Las Vegas approach was publicly revealed.
At that same hearing, Melgar’s mother, Nitza Melgar, addressed Matthews directly. He was not, she said, “a 17-year-old college frat boy out for a night on a lark” when the four men busted down her son’s door, pounced on him, and began binding him before he asphyxiated. “Logan was asleep,” she said. “He was attacked and minutes later was dead.” She told Matthews: “You, sir, are a murderer. Logan’s blood will never wash off of you.”
Where it stands now
No defendant was convicted of murder. Every felony murder charge in the case ended in a plea to lesser offenses, a dismissal as part of a plea agreement, or an acquittal at trial. The four outcomes, in the order they were resolved, were:
Adam C. Matthews — one year. On May 16, 2019, Matthews pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit assault, unlawful entry, obstruction of justice, and violating a general order by committing hazing; the felony murder and involuntary manslaughter charges did not stand as convictions. He was sentenced to one year of confinement, a reduction in rank to E-5, and a bad conduct discharge. He agreed to testify for the prosecution against the others.
Kevin Maxwell Jr. — four years. On June 7, 2019, Maxwell pleaded guilty to negligent homicide, conspiracy to commit assault, hazing, obstruction of justice, and making false official statements. He was sentenced to four years of confinement, a reduction in rank to E-1, and a bad conduct discharge. He also agreed to testify for the prosecution.
Anthony E. DeDolph — ten years, then eighteen months on resentencing. DeDolph, the man who applied the chokehold, pleaded guilty on January 23, 2021, to involuntary manslaughter, obstruction of justice, and hazing; the felony murder and burglary charges were dismissed under his pretrial agreement. He was initially sentenced to 10 years of confinement, reduction to E-1, forfeiture of pay, and a dishonorable discharge. That sentence was overturned on appeal because the prosecution had failed to disclose Maxwell’s reduced-sentence deal. On June 27, 2024, DeDolph was resentenced to 18 months of confinement, a reduction to E-4, and a bad conduct discharge.
Mario Madera-Rodriguez — convicted at trial; six months, no punitive discharge. Madera-Rodriguez was the only defendant to go to trial. He pleaded not guilty. On July 1, 2021, a military jury convicted him of involuntary manslaughter, conspiracy to commit assault and battery, conspiracy to obstruct justice, hazing, and making false statements, and of the lesser offense of housebreaking; he was found not guilty of felony murder. His sentence was a reprimand, reduction in rank to E-1, 90 days of hard labor without confinement, and six months of confinement — and, unlike the other three, no punitive discharge: no bad conduct discharge and no dishonorable discharge, and no forfeiture of pay or fine.
With that sentence, imposed in July 2021, the criminal cases arising from Logan Melgar’s death closed. The theft and corruption allegations that five fellow operators had described to reporters were never adjudicated in these proceedings. The motive question — hazing and retaliation for slights, as the defendants said, or silencing a man who had refused stolen money, as the other operators alleged and the defendants denied — remains, on the public record, unresolved.
Melgar is buried at Arlington National Cemetery.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The death was investigated by the Naval Criminal Investigative Service; the two SEALs were removed from Mali, the case passed from the Army to the Navy in September 2017, and by February 2018 the investigation had expanded into an internal audit of SEAL Team Six and implicated the two Marine Raiders.
- In November 2018, all four men were charged with felony murder, involuntary manslaughter, burglary, conspiracy, obstruction of justice, false statements, and hazing.
- All four cases were resolved: Matthews pleaded guilty in May 2019 (one year); Maxwell pleaded guilty in June 2019 (four years); DeDolph pleaded guilty in January 2021 (ten years, later vacated and resentenced in June 2024 to eighteen months); Madera-Rodriguez was convicted at trial in July 2021 (six months).
- The false first accounts did not survive the record: toxicology showed no alcohol or drugs in Melgar’s system, contrary to the claim that he was drunk, and the illness and training-accident explanations given to his widow were replaced, in court, by the defendants’ own admissions that the death followed a planned assault.
What has not been done
- No defendant was convicted of murder, although all four were charged with felony murder. The man who applied the chokehold, DeDolph, ultimately received eighteen months on resentencing in 2024. Madera-Rodriguez received six months and no punitive discharge.
- The motive was never adjudicated. The alleged theft of informant funds — and the allegation that Melgar was attacked to silence him after refusing a share — was denied by all four defendants and was never proven or disproven by a verdict in these cases.
- The family was not told the truth at the door. Michelle Melgar was told first that her husband died of illness, and then that he died in a training accident. She has said, on the record, that she had to fight to get the institution to accept that something more had happened.
What is being sought
- On the public record, the criminal accounting is closed: four resolutions, no murder conviction, and no further proceedings documented in the sources for this page. What the family sought from the beginning, in Michelle Melgar’s own words in court, was the truth — “I just wanted the truth” — and the record of pleas, testimony, and verdicts set out above is what the institution ultimately produced in answer to it, four years after the death and, in DeDolph’s resentencing, seven years after it.
Sources
- Todd South, Army Times, “Marine Raider arraigned on charges in death of Army Green Beret in Africa,” November 5, 2019 — the arraignment, the May and June 2019 pleas, the family’s courtroom statements, and the Las Vegas approach under a pseudonym, including the defense attorney’s response: https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2019/11/05/marine-raider-arraigned-on-charges-in-death-of-army-green-beret-in-africa/
- “Killing of Logan Melgar,” Wikipedia — index to the court reporting: the charges, the two motive accounts and their denials, the plea and trial outcomes, DeDolph’s vacated sentence and June 27, 2024 resentencing to 18 months, Madera-Rodriguez’s sentence, and the January 2019 Las Vegas encounter: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Logan_Melgar
- Todd South, Military Times, “Navy SEAL, Marine Raider hazing that killed Army Green Beret left an irreparable hole in the lives of family, friends,” May 17, 2019 — Matthews’ plea and testimony, the illness and combatives explanations given to Michelle Melgar, Nitza Melgar’s statement, and the cash-coverup reporting: https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2019/05/17/navy-seal-marine-raider-hazing-that-killed-army-green-beret-left-an-irreparable-hole-in-the-lives-of-family-friends/
- Military Times, “Report: Strangled Green Beret may have discovered SEALs’ illicit cash scheme,” November 13, 2017 — the informant-fund theft allegation, the refused offer of a share, the “bad feeling” emails shared with investigators, and the absence of alcohol in toxicology: https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2017/11/13/report-strangled-green-beret-may-have-discovered-seals-illicit-cash-scheme/
- Military Times, “Raiders, SEALs planned sexual assault in Green Beret hazing that led to homicide, Marine says,” June 5, 2019 — Maxwell’s stipulation of facts: the planned filmed sexual assault, the sledgehammer entry at about 5 a.m., and the planning at two Bamako bars: https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-army/2019/06/05/raiders-seals-planned-sexual-assault-in-green-beret-hazing-that-led-to-homicide/
- Military.com, “Marine Raider Convicted of Involuntary Manslaughter, Hazing in Green Beret’s Death,” July 2, 2021 — Madera-Rodriguez’s conviction, his acquittal on felony murder, and the other defendants’ outcomes: https://365.military.com/daily-news/2021/07/02/marine-raider-convicted-of-involuntary-manslaughter-hazing-green-berets-death.html
- Air Force Times, “Marine Raider gunny busted to private but no discharge in Green Beret hazing death,” July 12, 2021 — Madera-Rodriguez’s sentence: reprimand, reduction to E-1, 90 days’ hard labor without confinement, six months’ confinement, and no punitive discharge: https://www.airforcetimes.com/disaster/2021/07/12/marine-raider-gunny-busted-to-private-but-no-discharge-in-green-beret-hazing-death/
- Green Beret Foundation, memorial page for SSG Logan Melgar — Lubbock, enlistment in January 2012, assignment to 2nd Battalion, 3rd Special Forces Group (Airborne), two Afghanistan deployments, and his military education: https://greenberetfoundation.org/memorial/logan-melgar/
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.