Sarah Emma Edmonds: The Soldier Who Carried a Deserter's Label for Twenty Years
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
In April 1863 a private of the 2nd Michigan Infantry named Franklin Thompson fell sick with malaria, asked for a furlough, was refused, and — knowing that an Army hospital examination would expose the secret on which the whole service rested — left the regiment to find treatment elsewhere. The Army charged Franklin Thompson with desertion. Franklin Thompson was Sarah Emma Edmonds, and she then spent twenty years as the wife and mother in whose house a deserter's charge sat on the record of the name she had served under. This page is the documented record of the service, the charge, and the two decades of affidavits and acts of Congress it took to erase it.
The service, and the promise
Sarah Emma Edmonds was born in New Brunswick, Canada, in December 1841, and crossed into the United States as a young woman, settling at Flint, Michigan. She had already adopted male dress and the name Franklin Thompson to move and work freely — a disguise adopted, in her account, to escape an unwanted marriage and to earn her own living selling books. When the Civil War came, the disguise stayed on and acquired a regiment. On May 25, 1861, Franklin Thompson enlisted in Company F, 2nd Michigan Infantry — the Flint Union Greys.
The documented service is the service of a working soldier in a hard-used regiment. Edmonds served as a nurse in the regimental hospitals and as a mail carrier — regimental postmaster work that carried her, alone and on horseback, through country where a straggler could be shot — with the Army of the Potomac, through the Peninsula Campaign and the regiment’s subsequent service. Her wartime injuries were real and lifelong: thrown into a ditch on a night ride, she broke a leg and suffered internal injuries that, the American Battlefield Trust records, plagued her for the rest of her life and formed the basis of her later pension application. She nursed through the battles of the 2nd Michigan’s war and carried its mail, and no man in Company F, in two years, is recorded as having suspected who Franklin Thompson was.
A note on limits belongs here, because this site prints what the record supports and no more. Edmonds’s 1864 memoir, Nurse and Spy in the Union Army, made famous a second career — espionage behind Confederate lines in a series of disguises. Historians have disputed those spy exploits for a century and a half; some of the memoir’s details are demonstrably uncorroborated. The spy chapters are not used on this page. The documented core — enlistment and service as Franklin Thompson, nurse and mail carrier; malaria in 1863; the denied furlough; the desertion charge; the congressional pension and clearance; membership in the Grand Army of the Republic — is established by Army records, the pension file, and acts of Congress, and it needs no embellishment to make the case.
What happened
In the spring of 1863 the 2nd Michigan had been sent west, to Kentucky, with the Army of the Cumberland. There Edmonds contracted malaria. She requested a furlough to recover — the ordinary remedy the Army offered a sick soldier — and the furlough was denied.
The denial put her in the trap her whole service had been built to avoid. A soldier with malaria went to the hospital; a patient in a hospital was examined; an examination meant discovery — and discovery meant not merely dismissal but, under the military law of the day, punishment for the deception itself. Edmonds chose the third road. In mid-April 1863, she left the regiment, in civilian — in women’s — dress, and sought treatment privately, intending in her account to return when she was well. Franklin Thompson did not return. Franklin Thompson was posted as a deserter.
What followed for Edmonds herself is part of the documented record and cuts against any reading of the departure as shirking: she recovered, and — rather than disappear into private life under her own name while a death penalty theoretically attached to the name Thompson — she went to Washington and served out the rest of the war as a nurse under her real name with the United States Christian Commission, from June 1863 until the war’s end. In 1864 she published her memoir. In 1867 she married Linus Seelye, and they had three children, and for twenty years the family lived with the facts that govern this page: the soldier Franklin Thompson stood charged with desertion on the records of the United States Army, and because of that charge, the soldier’s wife could claim no pension, no back pay, and no bounty — nothing — for the two years of nursing and mail-carrying that had, among other things, permanently injured her.
What the institution did afterward
The correction, when it came, came the way such corrections came in the nineteenth century: not through the Army reviewing its own charge, but through the soldier’s comrades and the Congress overruling the file.
In 1876 Edmonds attended a reunion of the 2nd Michigan, and the men of Company F learned for the first time that Franklin Thompson stood among them. The record of the episode is unanimous: she was warmly received, and the regiment’s veterans became her advocates. In 1882 she began the formal campaign: she wrote to her old comrades and collected their affidavits — sworn statements from the men who had served beside Thompson attesting that Franklin Thompson and Sarah Emma Edmonds Seelye were the same person, and that the service had been faithful. In the House, her champion was Representative Byron M. Cutcheon of Michigan — himself a former colonel of Michigan infantry who had known Thompson in the war. On February 25, 1884, Cutcheon introduced two bills: one to add her to the pension roll, and one to remove the desertion charge.
The pension bill moved first. The House voted to grant her a pension of $12 a month on March 28, 1884; the Senate and President Chester A. Arthur followed by the first week of July 1884. Congress’s report stated the identity question plainly: that Franklin Thompson and Mrs. Sarah E. E. Seelye “are one and the same person is established by plenty of evidence and no doubt.”
The desertion charge took a second Congress. The House did not take up the removal bill until the following session; it passed in the summer of 1886, twenty-three years after the charge was entered. With the charge removed, she could at last collect the back pay and the $100 volunteer bounty the desertion had forfeited. In 1887 the Adjutant General’s office issued her a certificate of honorable discharge. In 1897 she was admitted to the Grand Army of the Republic — the great Union veterans’ organization — as its only woman member, mustered in as what she had been: a comrade.
She died on September 5, 1898, at La Porte, Texas, of the illnesses that had followed her service. Three years later, at the request of her GAR comrades, her remains were moved to the Grand Army of the Republic plot in Washington Cemetery, Houston, and reburied with the honors of a Union veteran.
Where it stands now
The record is closed and was closed, in the end, correctly: pension granted, charge removed, honorable discharge issued, comradeship recognized in the GAR. But the closing took from 1884 to 1887, and the ordeal ran from 1863. For two decades — the whole of her children’s growing up — Sarah Emma Edmonds Seelye lived as the household of a man the Army’s rolls called a deserter, for the act of leaving a malarial sickbed’s regiment to avoid being stripped and exposed in a military hospital. The Army that charged Thompson never weighed the reason; it took the man’s regiment, in affidavits, and two acts of Congress across two sessions, to make the file say what Company F had known since 1876.
The disputed spy tales have overshadowed the documented case, and this page has deliberately left them out: they are the reason her name is famous and the reason it is doubted, and neither matters to the ledger. The ledger is the twenty years. A soldier fell sick in service, asked for the ordinary furlough, was refused, and chose the only exit that did not end in a hospital examination and disgrace — and the institution’s books called it desertion until she was forty-five years old.
The ledger
What has been done
- 1884 — by act of Congress, Sarah Emma Edmonds was granted a pension of $12 a month as Franklin Thompson, on her comrades’ affidavits and the advocacy of Rep. Byron M. Cutcheon.
- 1886 — the desertion charge against Franklin Thompson was removed by act of Congress, releasing her back pay and the $100 volunteer bounty.
- 1887 — she received a certificate of honorable discharge.
- 1897 — she was admitted to the Grand Army of the Republic as its only woman member.
What has not been done
- The correction came two decades after the 1863 charge: the Army never revisited the charge on its own; it took comrades’ affidavits and two separate congressional efforts, in two Congresses, to clear it.
- Nothing in the record compensates the twenty years — her marriage and her three children’s childhoods — lived under the deserter’s label and without the pension.
What is being sought
- Nothing remains outstanding; the name was cleared in her lifetime, which distinguishes her case from most on this wall. What remains is that the case be remembered on its documented core — the malaria, the refused furlough, the charge, and the twenty-year road back — and not on the memoir’s disputed embellishments.
Sources
- U.S. House of Representatives, History, Art & Archives, “Application of Sarah E. E. Seelye for Back Pay” (House Record 25769819741) — service as Franklin Thompson in the Second Michigan Infantry; the 1863 illness and desertion; the forfeited pay and $100 bonus; Cutcheon’s two bills of February 25, 1884; the House pension vote of March 28, 1884 at $12 a month; the desertion bill’s passage in the summer of 1886: https://history.house.gov/HouseRecord/Detail/25769819741
- American Battlefield Trust, “Sarah Emma Edmonds” — the New Brunswick immigrant who enlisted as Franklin Thompson; nurse service and the lifelong injuries; malaria in the spring of 1863, the denied furlough, the departure in mid-April and the desertion charge; marriage to Linus Seelye in 1867 and three children; the 1876 reunion and comrades’ support; clearance of the charge and pension in 1884 after an eight-year battle; admission to the Grand Army of the Republic in 1897: https://www.battlefields.org/learn/biographies/sarah-emma-edmonds
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.