The SGLI Alliance Account Families: The Checkbook Sent Instead of the Check
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
They are not one family, and that is the point of this page. They are the widows, parents, and children of service members killed in the Iraq and Afghanistan era — in every branch — who did what the form asked, chose the lump sum, and opened an envelope that held no check. Inside was a checkbook, tied to an account most of them had never heard of, holding money that had never left the insurance company that owed it to them. This page is the documented record of that system: what it paid, what it earned, what the Department of Veterans Affairs knew, and what the families got when it was over.
The service, and the promise
Servicemembers’ Group Life Insurance — SGLI — is the life insurance Congress created for people in uniform, supervised by the Department of Veterans Affairs and administered, under contract with the VA, by Prudential since 1965. By 2010 the contract covered some 6 million service members, families, and veterans.
In the years this page covers, the maximum SGLI benefit was $400,000, payable either as a lump sum or in 36 equal monthly installments. About nine of every ten survivors chose the lump sum, according to the VA. By 2010, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan had claimed more than 4,000 American lives in combat, and in 2009 alone families were due death benefits totaling $1 billion, payable immediately under their policies.
The promise was not complicated: a family that chose the full amount up front would receive it up front — a check, to deposit where it chose. For more than a decade, that is not what arrived.
What happened
Beginning in June 1999, Prudential stopped mailing lump-sum checks to beneficiaries who had asked for them, and sent an Alliance Account kit instead.
The Alliance Account is a retained-asset account, and its mechanics are documented. The beneficiary’s money is not transferred to a bank in the beneficiary’s name. It stays in Prudential’s general corporate account, and Prudential invests it there. The beneficiary receives a book of drafts — instruments that look like checks, and in Prudential’s case carried the name of JPMorgan printed beside the Alliance Account’s name, although the money was not in that bank. Until a beneficiary writes a draft, nothing has left the company. As the FDIC’s 2010 consumer bulletin put it, retained-asset accounts “generally are not FDIC insured,” because the money sits as an insurance company liability, not a bank deposit; a state guaranty association stands behind it instead, with limits that vary by state.
Cindy Lohman of Great Mills, Maryland, learned how the system worked the way thousands of families did — from the envelope. Her son Ryan, a 24-year-old Army sergeant, was killed by a bomb in Afghanistan in August 2008, and was posthumously awarded the Purple Heart and the Bronze Star. About two weeks after she learned of his death, Prudential’s envelope arrived: a letter about Ryan’s $400,000 policy, and something that looked like a checkbook. The letter told her the full amount would be placed in a convenient, interest-bearing account: “You can hold the money in the account for safekeeping for as long as you like.”
Lohman, 52, believed the money was in a bank, insured by the FDIC. It was not. The only statement in the letter that the account was not guaranteed by the FDIC sat in tiny print — a disclaimer she says she did not notice. She left the money untouched for six months. When she later tried to spend it, the paper failed her in person: retailers rejected her “checks” — once for a bed, and again at a Target store on Armed Forces Day, May 15, for a camera. They were drafts — IOUs drawn on Prudential itself.
What Prudential did with the money while families waited is a matter of regulatory filings and VA-supplied figures. In 2008, Prudential paid survivors like Lohman 1 percent interest on their Alliance Accounts while earning a 4.8 percent return on its corporate funds. By July 2010 it was paying survivors 0.5 percent while its general account had earned 4.2 percent in 2009: as much as eight times what it paid the beneficiaries. As of June 30, 2010, Prudential held $662 million of survivors’ money in that account.
Prudential disputed the characterization that it was profiting at the families’ expense. Spokesman Bob DeFillippo said the account was helpful to families — “the difference between earning interest on a large amount of money and letting it sit idle” — that its terms were fully disclosed, and that the money could be withdrawn at any time by writing a draft. In an open letter dated September 23, 2010, the company stated that beneficiaries had always been able to get all of their money when they wanted it, and that Prudential “does not withhold a penny” of what belongs to beneficiaries.
Other facts were not explained to families at all. Under a 2008 law, SGLI survivors had one year to place death benefits into a Roth IRA, tax-free for life; Lohman says Prudential never told her. Inside the VA, Stephen Wurtz, the deputy assistant director for insurance who had overseen the program for 25 years, told Bloomberg he had believed the money went into a bank — and when he learned it stayed in Prudential’s general fund and asked how much it held and earned, Prudential declined to answer, calling it proprietary.
When Bloomberg explained the arrangement to Lohman, her answer entered the record in her own words: “I’m shocked. It’s a betrayal.”
What the institution did afterward
The paper trail, when it finally surfaced, showed that the checkbook system had never been in the contract families were promised under — and that the VA had agreed to it off the books. Prudential’s original 1965 contract with the VA, and the revised contract signed in 2007 as “amended in its entirety,” both required lump-sum payouts to survivors who requested them. The 1965 contract also required that any change be made in writing: “No change in the Group Policy shall be valid unless evidenced by an amendment thereto.” The 2007 revision repeated both rules and mentioned no earlier understanding.
The change had in fact been made in 1999, verbally. According to VA attorney Dennis Foley, the official who agreed to it was Thomas Lastowka, the VA’s director for insurance. In an e-mail dated June 9, 1999, released under a Freedom of Information request, Lastowka noted that the checkbook system was not protected by the FDIC, warned that the lack of coverage could backfire on survivors — “Who is responsible if Alliance goes belly up?” — and asked whether Prudential had alerted the agency to the non-FDIC fact, “or was it in small print as the notice to beneficiaries?” Prudential’s own June 10, 1998 presentation to the VA had carried the answer in fine print: “Funds in the Alliance Account are direct obligations of The Prudential Insurance Company of America and are not insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.”
The 1999 arrangement was put into writing only on September 24, 2009, in an amendment dated September 1, 2009, made retroactive only to that month — not back to 1999. The VA did not inform the 6 million covered soldiers and their families. Insurance lawyer Brendan Bridgeland stated the conclusion plainly: Prudential had violated the original terms.
On July 28, 2010, Bloomberg Markets, in reporting by David Evans, published the first account of the system. The VA launched a probe of its own life insurance program that same day. The next day, New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo opened a “major fraud investigation” of Prudential and other life insurers, with subpoenas to Prudential and at least twelve more companies. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates said he had been unaware survivors were being sent retained-asset accounts at all: “Until today I actually believed that the families of our fallen heroes got a check for the full amount of their benefits.”
On August 30, 2010, survivors filed a federal class action in Massachusetts — Lucey v. Prudential Insurance Company of America — alleging the company had earned as much as $500 million by keeping beneficiaries’ money instead of paying it out in a lump sum, and that it fraudulently presented the Alliance Account as a lump sum: “The Alliance Account is merely a bookkeeping device used by Prudential to hold on to beneficiaries’ money.”
On September 14, 2010, as a result of its probe, the VA announced it would change the program: Prudential would stop automatically sending checkbooks to survivors who asked for a lump sum, and would instead send a check when a beneficiary asked for a lump-sum payment. New documents would require the beneficiary to choose — a lump-sum check, an Alliance Account, or 36 monthly payments — with clearer disclosure that Alliance Account funds are not FDIC-insured. Prudential said it supported the changes and maintained it was in compliance with its contract; it declined to say whether it had been in compliance between 1999 and September 2009.
Where it stands now
The Alliance Account did not disappear. It was demoted — from the automatic destination of a family’s money to one option among three, available when a beneficiary affirmatively chooses it, alongside the lump-sum check promised since 1965. Retained-asset accounts remained a lawful, industry-wide product — an insurance company product, generally not FDIC insured, backed instead by state guaranty associations.
The litigation ended in settlement, not judgment. The cases were consolidated as In re: Prudential Insurance Company of America SGLI/VGLI Contract Litigation (Case No. 3:11-md-02208). In 2014, U.S. District Judge Michael A. Ponsor preliminarily approved a $39.2 million settlement fund, and the case was resolved that December. The class — 67,027 beneficiaries whose lump-sum claims before November 2010 had been settled through an Alliance Account — received $125 each, and Prudential additionally committed $20.5 million over five years in charitable contributions to veterans’ organizations. Prudential denied the allegations and acknowledged no wrongdoing.
The arithmetic of the ending is its own document. A family that left a $400,000 benefit untouched for a year at 0.5 percent earned $2,000 on it; the same sum at the 4.2 percent the general account earned in 2009 would have earned $16,800. The settlement paid each class member $125 — once — regardless of how long their money had been held, or how much it had earned, or for whom.
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- The arrangement was exposed and documented: Bloomberg Markets’ reporting of July 28, 2010 established the mechanics, and its September 14, 2010 FOIA reporting established the contract record behind it, including the unwritten 1999 agreement.
- The VA changed the program on September 14, 2010: lump-sum requesters would receive a check; new claim documents require an affirmative choice among a lump-sum check, an Alliance Account, or 36 monthly payments, with disclosure that Alliance Account funds are not FDIC-insured.
- Investigations were opened: a VA probe (July 28, 2010) and a New York attorney general fraud investigation with subpoenas to Prudential and at least twelve other insurers.
- The class litigation was resolved in December 2014: a $39.2 million settlement fund, $125 to each of 67,027 class members, and $20.5 million in charitable contributions over five years.
- In 2015, the internal Prudential documents were unsealed on the VFW’s motion, and the VA stated it had not known of the retention strategy they described.
What has not been done
- No court ever entered a judgment on the merits of the families’ claim that federal law and the contract required a lump sum; the case settled, with Prudential denying the allegations.
- The families were never repaid the documented spread — the difference between the 0.5 percent paid in 2010 and the 4.2 percent the account holding their money earned in 2009. The remedy was a flat $125 per class member, irrespective of balance or duration.
- The 1999 verbal agreement was never adjudicated: for ten years a federal insurance contract was administered on terms its written text forbade, the change was committed to writing only in September 2009 and made retroactive only to that month, and the 6 million covered service members and families were never informed of it by the VA.
- The FDIC question was disclosed, in Prudential’s 1998 presentation and in the letter Lohman received, only in fine print — the very placement Lastowka had questioned internally in 1999.
What is being sought
- Nothing on this page is a pending demand by this site. What the families sought in court is stated in their complaint of August 30, 2010: restitution of the retained funds’ earnings, disgorgement of Prudential’s gains, damages, and an end to settling a requested lump sum with a checkbook. They obtained the last of these in policy — the September 14, 2010 reform — and a fixed settlement in place of the rest.
- What remains sought, in the record the VFW carried forward, is the full public file: the unsealing it won in 2015 rested on the argument that families and the public are entitled to understand what was done, under a federal contract, with the fallen’s benefits.
Sources
- David Evans, Bloomberg Markets, “Fallen Soldiers’ Families Denied Cash as Insurers Profit,” July 28, 2010 — the Alliance Account mechanics, Cindy Lohman’s $400,000 benefit and rejected drafts, and the 2008 and July 2010 interest figures, as archived at Environmentalists Against War: http://www.envirosagainstwar.org/2010/08/04/fallen-soldiers-families-denied-cash-as-insurers-profit/
- David Evans, Bloomberg, “Veterans Agency Made Secret Deal Over Benefits,” September 14, 2010 — the FOIA contract record: the 1965 and 2007 lump-sum requirements, the 1999 verbal agreement and Lastowka’s June 9, 1999 e-mail, the September 1, 2009 amendment, $662 million held as of June 30, 2010, 4.2 percent earned in 2009 against 0.5 percent paid in 2010, and the VA’s September 14, 2010 program change, as archived at: https://www.911omissionreport.com/va_benefits.html
- Daily Insurance News, retained-asset account explainer (updated September 7, 2026) — the FDIC’s 2010 bulletin (“RAAs generally are not FDIC insured”) and state guaranty coverage: https://dailyinsurance.news/retained-asset-account-life-insurance-death-benefit-checkbook
- Lucey v. Prudential Insurance Company of America, First Amended Class Action Complaint, Case No. 3:10-cv-30163-MAP (D. Mass., filed August 30, 2010): http://wvbusinesslitigationblog.wp.lexblogs.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/514/2010/09/Lucey-v_-Prudential-Insurance-Company-of-America-a.pdf
- Top Class Actions, settlement reports (August and November 7, 2014) — the $39.2 million settlement, 67,027 class members at $125 each, and the $20.5 million charitable commitment, in In re: Prudential Insurance Co. of America SGLI/VGLI Contract Litigation, Case No. 3:11-md-02208: https://topclassactions.com/lawsuit-settlements/lawsuit-news/prudential-settles-military-death-benefits-class-action-lawsuit/ and https://topclassactions.com/lawsuit-settlements/lawsuit-news/plaintiffs-seek-ok-prudential-military-death-benefits-settlement/
- Prudential Financial, “An Open Letter to the Military Community,” September 23, 2010 — the company’s dispute of the profiting characterization: https://b5d7ac.staticwbm.com/20131110144641/http://news.prudential.com/images/20026/AnOpenLettertotheMilitaryCommunity.pdf
- U.S. Department of Defense / DVIDS, “Council Works to End Life Insurance Compensation Confusion” — the post-reform claim-form options: https://www.dvidshub.net/news/60516/council-works-end-life-insurance-compensation-confusion
- Veterans of Foreign Wars, “VFW’s Motion Granted: Unseal Prudential’s SGLI Records,” August 26, 2015, and Military.com coverage of the 2015 release: https://www.vfw.org/media-and-events/latest-releases/archives/2015/8/vfws-motion-granted-unseal-prudentials-sgli-records
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.