IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

The USCT Widows: Wives Without Certificates, Made to Prove They Had Been Wives at All

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

The United States asked more than 100,000 Black men to fight for its survival, and most of them had been enslaved when the war began. When those men died in uniform, the government owed their widows a pension — the one promise the system made to the families of the dead. But the promise came with a condition that slavery had made impossible to meet: proof of a legal marriage. This page is the documented record of what that condition cost the widows of the United States Colored Troops — women like Nancy Douglas, who was still answering the Pension Bureau's questions in 1888, twenty-four years after her husband died.

The service, and the promise

Over 100,000 African American men served in the United States Army during the Civil War, the majority of them Southerners who had once been slaves. They served in segregated regiments, under white officers, in a war whose outcome would decide whether they and their families remained property. Their service carried a promise, and the promise was written into pension law: the pension records, as the National Archives’ own historian Noralee Frankel wrote in Prologue, “were originally created so that widows of soldiers could receive monthly compensation for the loss of their husbands.” A soldier who died in service left his widow a claim on the government he had died serving. That was the bargain.

Consider one soldier of the 68th United States Colored Troops. Manuel Price was born into slavery around 1842 in Albemarle County, Virginia. His owner, John Coles Carter, moved from Virginia to Missouri in 1852, taking the people he owned with him; by 1860 Carter held 126 slaves. In Missouri, Price married Nancy Scott, a woman born in Albemarle County around 1838 who had been rented out by her owner, Archibald Bankhead, to work as a nurse. They were married at Thomas Cobb’s house around the turn of the year, between December 25, 1863, and January 1, 1864, and they lived together on Lick Farm in Lincoln County, Missouri — Price’s brother and Nancy’s sister, also married to each other, lived alongside them. Nancy had three children from before the marriage. It was a real marriage in every sense their community recognized. In law, it did not exist.

On February 28, 1864, Price enlisted as a private in the Union Army at Louisiana, Missouri, for a term of three years. He was mustered into Company D of the 68th USCT Infantry on March 10, 1864, at Benton Barracks in St. Louis; his enlistment records describe a man five feet eleven inches tall, with black hair, black eyes, and a dark complexion. He was twenty-two years old, and he had been a free man, in the eyes of the government he was now serving, for a matter of weeks.

What happened

Price never reached his regiment’s war. The 68th USCT — formally organized as the 4th Missouri Colored Infantry — was attached to the District of Memphis, Tennessee, as part of the 16th Corps. Price did not go with it. He died at the post hospital at Benton Barracks on April 14, 1864, of complications from pneumonia, thirty-five days after his muster and forty-six days after his enlistment. He had been a soldier for a month and a half, and he died, as so many Civil War soldiers of every color died, of disease in a camp hospital before he ever saw the enemy.

His death made Nancy Price — as she now was — a widow with a claim. And here the record turns. The pension system she faced had been built on an assumption her life could not satisfy. As the National Archives’ account states plainly: “Originally, pension law only recognized legal marriages and ignored slave marriages. Slaves did not possess legal documentation, like a marriage certificate, for use as evidence in a widow’s pension claim.” The granting of pensions to formerly enslaved women was, in Frankel’s word, “tricky” — because slave marriages “were not governed by a contractual agreement as were civil marriages and were not considered legal.”

So the widow of a man who had died in the United States Army could not do what every other widow did. She could not mail in a marriage license, because no license had ever existed. She had to reconstruct her marriage, years after the fact, out of other people’s memories: the date of the wedding, who had officiated, where the couple had lived, the names and ages of the children, who had attended the births. The pension files are thick, Frankel notes, precisely because of this: “Since formerly enslaved women could not simply mail in their marriage licenses to obtain their widow’s pensions, they provided oral testimony on their marriages and the births of their children.” Pension officials relied on members of the claimant’s own community to identify her and vouch for her life. Witnesses described weddings held in plantation houses decades earlier. One former dining-room servant, Andrew Walker, testifying for the widow Martha Brown, recalled of her marriage: “I was a dining room servant on the Edmund Randall plantation . . . and they were married in the white folks house by our marster Edmund Randall.” That was the quality of evidence the system demanded — and it demanded it from women who had been forbidden by law from creating any better.

To the system’s credit, Nancy’s claim moved at first. She began receiving a pension of eight dollars a month on April 15, 1864 — the day after her husband’s death. The government that had owned no obligation to her as a wife under slavery paid her as a widow of the United States Army. But the payment carried the system’s conditions, and the conditions would follow her for the rest of her life.

What the institution did afterward

Congress knew the problem it had created, and it repaired the law — partly, and always in the direction of keeping the burden on the widow. In 1864, Congress amended the pension law to provide “that the widows and children of colored soldiers . . . shall be entitled to receive the pensions now provided by law, without other proof of marriage than that the parties had habitually recognized each other as man and wife, and lived together as such for a definite period, not less than two years, to be shown by the affidavits of credible witnesses.” Read it closely: the marriage still had to be proven — by affidavit, by witnesses, by a minimum of two years of recognized cohabitation. A white widow produced a certificate. A Black widow produced her neighbors.

The 1864 provision was repealed two years later and replaced. The act of June 6, 1866, required no “other evidence of marriage than proof, satisfactory to the Commissioner of Pensions, that the parties have habitually recognized each other as man and wife, and lived together as such” — and it eliminated distinctions among states in which Black claimants could or could not legally marry. Then, on June 15, 1873, Congress tightened the standard again: a Black widow now had to supply evidence that she and her husband “were joined in marriage by some ceremony deemed by them obligatory.” Each reform conceded the principle and preserved the obstacle. The widows’ marriages were real enough to pension — after the widows proved them, to the satisfaction of the Commissioner of Pensions, in whatever form the current statute demanded.

And the proof never ended at the wedding. A pension was not a settlement; it was a continuing relationship with a bureau that watched. “Evidence of cohabitation or remarriage,” the Archives’ account records, “would lead pension examiners to reopen the claim and seek out more testimony.” Examiners interviewed people, white and Black, who knew the claimant — especially when a claim was contested. A widow’s private life after her husband’s death was the government’s business for as long as she drew his pension. The file of Lucy Brown of Mississippi — documented in the same Archives study — shows the machinery at work: her wartime marriage, her legal remarriage by a Union chaplain, and then, after her second husband’s death, examiners recording testimony from her neighbors about the men she had been intimate with in between. The pension she depended on could be reopened on the strength of gossip about her conduct, and her neighbors’ recollections of her private life became part of her federal file.

Nancy Price’s own file carries the system’s logic to its conclusion. On March 3, 1866, she married William Douglass. Under the pension law, a widow’s remarriage ended her pension — not reduced it, ended it — whatever her circumstances and whatever her first husband had died doing. The eight dollars a month stopped. She was, in the Bureau’s eyes, no longer Manuel Price’s widow; she was William Douglass’s wife, and Douglass would provide. Nancy Douglas lived the next twenty-two years outside the pension system her first husband’s death had entitled her to enter. Only when Douglass himself died was she pensioned again — in 1888, twenty-four years after Price died at Benton Barracks, she received another pension as a widow. She had to be widowed twice before the government of the United States would support her once. Around the same time, a woman named Lucy Rose, who claimed to be Manuel Price’s daughter, filed for a minor’s pension on his service. Her claim was rejected.

That is the pattern this page exists to record: the service was accepted at once and in full; the obligation was audited for decades. The men of the USCT were believed when they enlisted. Their widows were cross-examined when they claimed.

Where it stands now

There is no pending remedy, because there is no one left to remedy it for. The widows are all dead, and the pensions died with them. What remains is the record they were forced to create — and it is, by the bitterest of ironies, one of the richest archives of Black family life in the nineteenth century that exists. The testimony the Pension Bureau extracted from these women and their neighbors — the weddings, the births, the midwives, the communities — is now held by the National Archives and studied by historians precisely because the Bureau demanded it. “It was the complicated procedures involved in documenting nonlegal slave marriages that make these pension records so rich for women’s and family history,” Frankel wrote. The proof of their marriages survived because the government refused to take their word for them.

The University of Virginia’s Nau Center project Black Virginians in Blue has rebuilt individual records from those files — Manuel Price’s compiled service record and pension file among them, including Nancy Douglas’s own testimony, preserved as a document in her name. His entry records the whole arc in a few lines: enlisted February 28, 1864; dead April 14, 1864; his widow pensioned, cut off at her remarriage, pensioned again in 1888. Nothing in the record shows the government ever acknowledging the design flaw it had built — that it demanded certificates from people it had forbidden to obtain them, and surveillance from widows whose only offense was surviving their husbands. The widows carried their husbands’ service into the only form of recognition available to them, and they carried it for decades. This page carries their names the same way: Nancy Douglas, who was Nancy Scott, who was Mrs. Manuel Price — a wife the law made prove she had ever been one.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members, veterans, and families their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door