Matthew Holley: The Medic Flown Home as Freight, and the Law His Parents Forced
English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog
Matthew John Holley was twenty-one years old, a medic his fellow soldiers called "Doc," and he died doing the work he had chosen — helping others who were hurting. What happened to him in Iraq is in the casualty record. What his government planned to do with his body afterward is in the news record, in a congressman's letter, and finally in a statute. This page is that record: the standard practice that treated America's fallen as airline freight, and the law his parents forced so no family after theirs would be handed a casket in a cargo warehouse.
The service, and the promise
Matthew John Holley was born in Idaho and grew up in Chula Vista, California. He enlisted in the U.S. Army in the footsteps of his parents — both of them, unusually, veterans of the same division he would serve in. “It made me very proud that he actually wanted to be like his dad,” his father, John Holley, said in December 2005.
He was a young man of more than one gift: a three-time AAU national champion in karate, and an artist of what his mother, Stacey Holley, called “extremely artistic talent.” He chose to be a medic — in his father’s later words, he wanted to “serve a cause greater than himself” and chose the medic’s work “so he could help others who were hurting.” His fellow soldiers knew him as “Doc.” He was engaged to be married. Days before he died, he asked his family to send him crayons so he could teach Iraqi children how to draw. In 2004, at nineteen, he wrote what his father later called “Matthew’s Prayer”: “Lord, some things in life are unrevealed. Some things are never to be known.”
The Defense Department’s casualty record gives his assignment in one line: Spc. Matthew J. Holley, 21, of San Diego, California, assigned to the 1st Battalion, 320th Field Artillery Regiment, 101st Airborne Division, Fort Campbell, Kentucky.
The promise made to a soldier like Matthew Holley has a second half, and every family in the record understood it without being told. If he did not come home alive, he would come home with honor: a flag-draped coffin, greeted by a color guard. As the San Diego station that first reported this story put it in December 2005: “Dead heroes are supposed to come home with their coffins draped with the American flag — greeted by a color guard.” What the Holleys learned, in the worst week of their lives, was that this was not the system. It was the exception — available, as it turned out, mainly to families who knew enough to demand it.
What happened
On November 15, 2005, in Taji, Iraq, an improvised explosive device detonated near Holley’s HMMWV during combat operations. The Defense Department’s record states the outcome in its standard formula: he “died of injuries sustained in Taji, Iraq, when an improvised explosive device detonated near his HMMWV during combat operations.”
He did not die alone. The same blast, the same battalion, killed three other soldiers:
- Staff Sgt. James E. Estep, 26, of Leesburg, Florida — died November 15, 2005, in Taji, in the same recorded circumstances.
- Pfc. Travis J. Grigg, 24, of Inola, Oklahoma — died November 15, 2005, in Taji, in the same recorded circumstances.
- Spc. Alexis Roman-Cruz, 33, of Brandon, Florida — died November 16, 2005, in Balad, Iraq, of injuries sustained on November 15 in Taji.
Sixteen years later, John Holley stated the total as he has always carried it: “That day, four young men lost their lives for the cause of freedom. Not so much for ours, but for people they barely knew.”
On December 2, 2005, family and friends in San Diego said goodbye to the Holleys’ only child. Matthew Holley received full military honors, including three medals for his service. That part of the promise was kept.
The other part was not — and it is the part this site exists to document. After a fallen service member’s remains reached the military mortuary at Dover Air Force Base, Delaware, the standard practice in 2005 was for the journey home to continue as freight on a commercial airliner: the casket carried in the cargo hold — “stuffed in the belly of a plane with suitcases and other cargo,” in the contemporaneous reporting’s words — unloaded by airline baggage handlers, in some cases, the Associated Press later documented, by forklift, and handed over to the family at a cargo warehouse. Some families were met by uniformed honor guards. Others were not. There was no guaranteed escort and no guaranteed honor guard. That was the plan for Matthew Holley: arrival at San Diego’s Lindbergh Field as freight, collected by his parents in the freight area.
John Holley was told by an airline executive, in the Associated Press’s account, that this was the “most expeditious” way to get the body home. His answer is in the record:
“I said, ‘That’s not going to happen with my son. That’s not how my son is coming home.’ … If it was ’expeditious’ to deliver them in garbage trucks, would you do that?”
“When someone dies in combat, they need to give them due respect they deserve for (the) sacrifice they made,” he told 10News in San Diego. Military officials, the AP reported, defended the commercial practice as the fastest way to return the dead to their families. When 10News called the Defense Department in December 2005 and asked for an explanation, a representative said she did not know why this was happening.
Both parents had served. They made calls, and said on the record why their knowledge was itself the indictment. With the help of U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer of California, Matthew was met at Lindbergh Field by an honor guard from his own unit at Fort Campbell, and John Holley called the ceremony dignified and fitting. Stacey Holley explained what had made the difference, and for whom it would not have:
“Our familiarity with military protocol and things of that sort allowed us to kind of put our foot down — we’re not sure other parents have that same knowledge.”
The Holleys stated their intention in the same report: to make sure every fallen hero got the proper welcome.
What the institution did afterward
For Matthew Holley himself, what the institution did was the honor guard — obtained by his parents’ intervention, not provided by the system. For everyone else, what it did afterward happened because the family did not stop at their own son’s tarmac.
John Holley complained to his congressman, Rep. Duncan Hunter of California, then chairman of the House Armed Services Committee. In December 2005, Hunter wrote to Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld calling for more appropriate military honors for the fallen; the following May, on the House floor, he said the extreme respect owed to fallen heroes had in some cases been lacking. Senator Boxer’s office urged support for the House provision requiring that remains be transferred by military aircraft and escorted at all times by a service member of appropriate rank.
Congress passed the law. The provision — known since as the Holley Provision — was enacted on October 17, 2006, as Section 562 of Public Law 109-364, and by its own terms took effect not later than January 1, 2007. What it requires is the opposite of freight:
- Military carriage. Remains returned through Dover are transported onward by military aircraft or military-contracted aircraft. Air transportation by other means is permitted only to the extent the person designated to direct disposition of the remains directs otherwise.
- The flight exists for the fallen. When remains are transported under the provision, “the primary mission of the aircraft providing that transportation shall be the transportation of such remains.”
- A continuous escort. The remains are “continuously escorted from Dover Air Force Base to the applicable escorted remains destination by a member of the Armed Forces in an appropriate grade.”
- An honor guard, in addition to the escort. Except where the family requests that no honor guard be present, the service must provide an honor guard detail, in uniform, to provide appropriate honors at the arrival of the remains, where airport and security requirements permit, and to carry out the remains, a flag draped over the casket, to the hearse for travel to the place the family designates.
The Pentagon’s on-record response, given to the Associated Press in April 2007 by spokesman Maj. Stewart Upton, came in the language of perception: whatever the reality had been, there had been a perception that proper respect was not being provided to those who made the ultimate sacrifice — a perception that, he said, was no longer a question.
The change took effect in January 2007, for the fallen of Afghanistan as well as Iraq. The Pentagon contracted Kalitta Charters of Ypsilanti, Michigan, to fly the missions; by the AP’s count on April 6, 2007, Kalitta had returned 143 bodies since January 1. The economics are in the record: about $1.2 million spent on commercial flights in the prior year; a six-month Kalitta contract worth up to $11 million. Instead of the nearest commercial airport and its cargo warehouse, the fallen were now flown into smaller regional airports closer to their hometowns and borne from the plane by an honor guard. Kalitta’s project manager, Steve Greene, identified the image that had forced the issue — a forklift unloading a casket, with a family watching: “You just don’t do that.”
John Holley had said it in a father’s words: “What about all these other parents? This is one of the last memories. I don’t want it to be in a warehouse on a forklift.”
Where it stands now
The freight system did not return. The Holley Provision remains the governing standard for the homeward journey of America’s combat dead: military or military-chartered aircraft out of Dover, a continuous escort, and an honor guard at the arrival — not as a favor, but as a requirement of law, waivable only at the family’s own direction. Every fallen service member flown home since January 1, 2007, has traveled under the rule two grieving parents from San Diego forced into the United States Code.
What the record does not contain is equally plain: no apology to the families who collected caskets at cargo warehouses, and no explanation — the Defense Department’s answer at the time was that its representative did not know why it was happening. It was defended, while it lasted, only as the fastest and most expeditious method, and it ended only when Congress made it unlawful. The institution did not correct itself; it was corrected, by statute, at the demand of the governed.
The Holleys are still on the record. On Memorial Day 2021 — sixteen years after Taji — John and Stacey Holley stood before crowds in Idaho, the state where Matthew was born, and told his story again. John Holley read “Matthew’s Prayer” aloud and, struggling to finish it as his wife placed a hand on his back, called it what it was: “That is the true heart of a warrior.”
The ledger
The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.
What has been done
- For Matthew Holley himself: after his parents’ intervention, with Sen. Barbara Boxer’s office’s help, an honor guard from his unit at Fort Campbell met his body at Lindbergh Field, and he received full military honors at his December 2, 2005 memorial.
- December 2005: Rep. Duncan Hunter, chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, wrote to Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld calling for more appropriate military honors for the fallen.
- October 17, 2006: the Holley Provision was enacted as Section 562 of Public Law 109-364 — military or military-contracted aircraft, as the aircraft’s primary mission, under continuous escort, with an honor guard at arrival — effective not later than January 1, 2007.
- January–April 2007: the new system operated. Kalitta Charters, under a six-month contract worth up to $11 million (against $1.2 million spent on commercial flights the prior year), had returned 143 bodies by April 6, 2007, to regional airports, met by honor guards.
What has not been done
- No explanation was ever given for the freight practice itself. In December 2005 the Defense Department’s representative told 10News she did not know why it was happening; its only defenses in the record are speed and, afterward, the Pentagon’s framing of the failure as one of perception.
- The change was not made voluntarily. The standard practice continued until a grieving family refused it, a congressman carried it, and a statute prohibited it; the law, not the institution’s own review, ended shipment of the fallen as commercial freight.
- For the families who came before: the record shows no remedy and no apology for the caskets unloaded by forklift and collected at cargo warehouses before January 1, 2007. The honor guard the Holleys obtained was, by Stacey Holley’s own account, a product of knowledge other parents could not be assumed to have.
What is being sought
- What the Holleys sought is stated in the December 2005 record: that every fallen hero get the proper welcome — not the families with protocol knowledge, not the families with a senator’s help, every one. The statute is that demand, enacted; what is being sought now is that it be kept — the escort, the honor guard, and the flag-draped transfer, on every flight, for as long as Americans are brought home from war.
- And the simpler thing the family has sought in public for sixteen years: that Matthew Holley be remembered as he was — a medic, an artist, a three-time karate champion who asked for crayons for Iraqi children days before his death — not as a line in a shipping system his parents had to abolish.
Sources
- Bill Poovey, Associated Press, “Fallen of war fly home with more dignity,” April 6, 2007 (as republished at Silicon Investor): https://www.siliconinvestor.com/readreplies.aspx?msgid=23435326
- 10News San Diego, “Family Upset Over Soldier’s Body Arriving As Freight,” December 9, 2005, and “Family, Friends Mourn Local Soldier,” December 2, 2005 (as archived at Steve’s Soapbox, December 2005): http://stevesmarketanddeli.com/2005_12_01_
- Fallen Heroes of Operation Iraqi Freedom (sourcing DefenseLINK), casualty listing by date — the November 15, 2005 Taji casualties of the 1st Battalion, 320th Field Artillery Regiment: https://www.fallenheroesmemorial.com/oif/?dates=20050712
- Public Law 109-364, §562, October 17, 2006, as printed at 10 U.S.C. §1482a note (2012 ed.): https://statecodesfiles.justia.com/us/2012/title-10/subtitle-a/part-ii/chapter-75/subchapter-ii/section-1482a/section-1482a.pdf
- Friends of Barbara Boxer, “San Diego Regional Highlights” — Boxer’s intervention: https://eastcountymagazine.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/07/San-Diego-Regional-Highlights-92b.pdf
- Bill Buley, Hagadone News Network, “‘The true heart of a warrior,’” June 1, 2021 — the Holleys speaking on Memorial Day 2021: https://hagadonenewsnetwork.com/news/2021/jun/01/true-heart-warrior/
Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.