IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Raheel Siddiqui: The Recruit Whose Drill Instructor Was Ordered Away From Recruits — and Was Not

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Raheel Siddiqui was twenty years old, eleven days into recruit training at Parris Island, and unable to speak above a whisper. He handed his drill instructors a note asking to go to medical. He did not get medical care. He got run across the squad bay until he collapsed, and slapped by a senior drill instructor who had already been ordered — in writing and out loud — to stay away from recruits while investigated for abusing another Muslim recruit. Minutes later, Siddiqui fell forty feet from a barracks stairwell and died. The Marine Corps ruled his death a suicide. His family has never accepted that ruling, and this page does not ask the reader to: it sets the official finding and the family's dispute side by side, then follows the part no one disputes — the orders given, the orders not obeyed, and what the institution did about each man in the chain afterward, in dates, verdicts, and dollars.

The service, and the promise

Raheel Siddiqui was a native of Taylor, Michigan, studying at the University of Michigan–Dearborn and working for a department store when a Marine Corps recruiter approached him. On July 8, 2015, he signed enlistment papers, and on August 1, 2015, he entered the Delayed Entry Program, spending eight months in part-time training as a member of the Marine Corps Reserve. On his enlistment forms he indicated that he was Muslim, and he was open with his recruiter about his faith — a fact his family’s lawsuit later placed at the center of the case, alleging the recruiters never warned him about the abuse of other Muslim recruits at the depot he was being sent to.

On March 7, 2016, Siddiqui was sent to the Recruit Depot at Parris Island, South Carolina, where he signed the form discharging him from the Delayed Entry Program and accepting enlistment in the regular United States Marine Corps at the rank of private. Later that week he was assigned to Platoon 3042, Company K, Third Recruit Training Battalion, under senior drill instructor Gunnery Sergeant Joseph A. Felix, Jr.

The promise made to a recruit is basic: you will be taken to medical when you are injured, and the men placed over you are men the institution has cleared to be there. In Siddiqui’s case, the second part had already been withdrawn before he arrived — on paper. Neither Siddiqui nor his family knew Felix had allegedly abused another Muslim recruit at Parris Island while intoxicated. What the institution knew, and when, is the spine of this record.

What happened

Felix was under investigation before Siddiqui ever met him. The earlier case, from 2015, involved another Muslim recruit: Felix was accused of making him exercise in the shower, then ordering him to sit in a commercial dryer, turning it on several times while taunting him about his religion, including asking whether he had taken part in the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Because of those allegations, Col. Paul D. Cucinotta, commanding officer of the Recruit Training Regiment, gave verbal and written orders that Felix not return to drill instructor duty until the investigation was completed. Prosecutors would later say that Lt. Col. Joshua Kissoon, commanding the Third Recruit Training Battalion, wrongly allowed Felix to oversee Siddiqui’s platoon anyway. Exactly how Felix became Siddiqui’s drill instructor, Marine Corps Times reported in December 2017, “has not been fully explained.”

Inside that battalion, the command investigation documented the climate. The battalion was known as “Thumpin’ Third” for its reputation for physical treatment of recruits. Its drill instructors “routinely used excessive force” by slapping and choking recruits, justifying it as “drill corrections,” and Platoon 3042’s drill instructors directed recruits to assault other recruits and authorized physical force to enforce rules in the squad bay and classrooms.

On March 13, 2016 — after less than one full day of training, by the family’s complaint — Siddiqui threatened to commit suicide and told military police a supervisor had physically hit him. He was not taken to the hospital. The next day he retracted the threat, was deemed at “low risk for harm,” and was returned to training. The command investigation later established what that decision missed: Siddiqui had a specific plan for how he intended to kill himself, and had the mental health unit known it, he would have been separated from the Marine Corps with a diagnosis of suicidal ideation. His leaders did not report the information, and his allegation of being hit was never properly reported either. The investigation found “multiple errors and omissions, to include failures to supervise and take required actions by a number of officers and staff non-commissioned officers in the recruit’s chain of command, some of which rose to the level of dereliction of duty” — and that the recruit had been declared fit to train “when there were clear indications he should have been disqualified.”

On March 17, the platoon practiced mixed-martial-arts punching techniques. The family’s complaint alleged that, as was typical for “weaker” recruits in such exercises, Siddiqui was paired with a bigger, stronger recruit and sustained serious injuries.

On the morning of March 18, 2016, Siddiqui could barely speak. He gave a supervisor a note, preserved in the court record:

This recruit has to go to medical. This recruit’s throat has been swollen for three days and is getting worse. This recruit also coughed blood a few times last night. And this recruit completely lost his voice and can barely whisper. This recruit’s whole neck is in a lot of pain.

He was not permitted to go to medical and was given no medical attention. What happened next is established by the investigation as reported by Marine Corps Times: Siddiqui asked Felix to be sent to medical for his sore throat. When he failed to give the proper greeting of the day, Felix forced him to run back and forth across the squad bay until he passed out. Felix slapped him — between one and three times while he was on the floor; Felix claimed he was trying to revive him, and the Sixth Circuit’s summary records Felix rubbing his sternum and slapping him to revive him. Siddiqui got up, ran to the nearby stairwell, went over the railing, and fell forty feet to his death.

The contested finding, stated plainly. The Marine Corps ruled Siddiqui’s death a suicide. His family disputes that ruling: through their attorney they dismissed it as unsupported by the evidence, and their lawsuit alleged his death was the result of torture and forced inhumane treatment, not suicide, and that the investigation that labeled it a suicide made it harder for the family to seek justice in court. The investigation itself, as Marine Corps Times reported it, could not determine whether Siddiqui was trying to kill himself or trying to get away from Felix. Those are the two positions, labeled as what they are: an official ruling, and a family that refuses to accept it, with the institution’s own investigators unable to settle the question of intent.

What the institution did afterward

The command investigation recommended punitive and administrative action against several Marines, including Felix and Lt. Col. Kissoon. Up to 20 Marines faced punishment or administrative action after the investigations found rampant abuse at Parris Island. Col. Cucinotta, the regimental commander who had ordered Felix away from recruits, and Sgt. Maj. Nicholas Deabreu, the regiment’s senior enlisted leader, were fired on June 6, 2016, as a result of the investigation into Siddiqui’s death. Kissoon had already been fired as battalion commander on March 31, 2016. The Marine Corps also added company-grade officers and second-tour drill instructors at its recruit depots to provide additional supervision, with Lt. Gen. Mark Brilakis stating the diagnosis on the record — “what we had was a failure in supervision and a failure to adhere to standards.”

Then came the courts-martial, and the distance between the two sentences at the center of this case is the institution’s own measure of itself.

Gunnery Sgt. Joseph Felix was convicted at court-martial in 2017 of violating orders, maltreatment, false official statements, and drunk and disorderly conduct. The evidence at his trial reached well beyond Siddiqui: prosecutors said Felix, sometimes drunk, routinely called Muslim recruits “terrorist”, forced one to simulate chopping off the head of another Marine while yelling “Allahu akbar,” and forced Muslim recruits into an industrial dryer. Lance Cpl. Ameer Bourmeche testified that Felix and fellow drill instructor Sgt. Michael Eldridge let him out of the dryer only after he told them he was no longer a Muslim. Those incidents allegedly happened before Siddiqui shipped to boot camp — why Felix was supposed to be nowhere near a platoon when Siddiqui arrived. On November 10, 2017, Felix was sentenced to ten years’ confinement, reduction in rank to private (E-1), forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and a dishonorable discharge.

Lt. Col. Joshua Kissoon, the battalion commander — the highest-ranking officer charged in the recruit-abuse cases — pleaded guilty in March 2018 to dereliction of duty, making false official statements, and conduct unbecoming an officer. A core part of the dereliction charge was his failure to remove Felix from contact with recruits despite being told to do so by Col. Cucinotta and the colonel’s subordinates. His sentence: a reprimand and a reduction in pay of $1,000 a month for five months. At sentencing, the military judge, Navy Capt. Charles Purnell, cited a “myriad failure of leadership” and said Kissoon’s actions were only “one in a legion of contributing causes” to Siddiqui’s death. The commander who did not carry out the order paid $5,000. The drill instructor he failed to remove got ten years. Both numbers are the institution’s, entered in its own courts.

Where it stands now

The family’s civil case is closed, and it was closed without any court ever weighing whether the Marine Corps was negligent — because under the law that governs these cases, no court was permitted to.

Ghazala and Masood Siddiqui sued under the Federal Tort Claims Act in 2017, seeking $100 million: recruiters negligently misled their son into enlisting without warning him about the abuse of Muslim recruits at Parris Island; the Corps assigned him to officers already under investigation for abusing another Muslim recruit; it failed to protect him from discriminatory abuse that led to his death; and it failed to investigate his death fully. The district court dismissed the case on November 27, 2018 — while recording its “strong reservations about the continued viability of the Feres doctrine” — and a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed on August 6, 2019.

Feres v. United States (1950) holds the government is not liable under the Federal Tort Claims Act for injuries arising out of activity incident to service. The Sixth Circuit held itself bound by it: Siddiqui was on active duty when he died, his death in basic training fell “squarely within the wide reach of the Feres doctrine,” and the family’s claims — including that the negligence began with his recruitment — called into question “basic choices about the discipline, supervision, and control of a serviceman.” The court did not hide what that meant in dollars. Quoting the district court, it wrote that the doctrine’s reliance on “generous” no-fault compensation “has not withstood the test of time,” that a $100,000 death benefit and a $400,000 insurance payout “are mere fractions of most wrongful death awards” — the September 11th Fund’s awards ran $2–3 million — and that “Private Siddiqui’s death benefit is woefully out-of-step with such principles.” Then it affirmed anyway: “Unless and until the Supreme Court overturns Feres, we remain bound by the Feres doctrine.”

The family asked the Supreme Court to do exactly that. Their petition was docketed on January 22, 2020. In March 2020, the Supreme Court declined to hear the case, giving no reason. That denial is the last entry in the legal record: no trial, no finding on negligence, no damages.

What remains open is the question the courts never reached: how a twenty-year-old who had reported being hit, who had named a plan to kill himself five days earlier, and who could not speak above a whisper on his last morning, was in a squad bay at all — under a drill instructor his regiment had already ordered off the drill field.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door