IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Sue Frasier: Five Months at Fort McClellan, Thirty-Nine Years of Appeals

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Most of the people on this wall are dead, and the rest of this page would be simpler to write if Susan Frasier were among them. She is not. She is a living veteran — a woman who played percussion in an Army band for five months in 1970, filed her first VA application weeks after her honorable discharge in 1972, and was still appealing thirty-nine years later. In her own words, her life has been "ruined, destroyed." She made herself the lead spokesperson for every veteran who passed through Fort McClellan, and for years she rode an overnight Greyhound bus to Washington, alone, once a month, to walk the halls of Congress — because the VA's New York office kept saying no, and because a bill with her cause in it kept dying in committee. This page is the documented record, written while its subject is alive to read it.

The service, and the promise

Susan “Sue” Frasier of Albany, New York, served in the Women’s Army Corps at Fort McClellan, Alabama, in 1970 — from July through November, five months. The Army assigned her to the 14th Army WAC Band: she played percussion in the marching band and twelve-string guitar in its dance band, performing at officers’ clubs. Fort McClellan was then the home of the Women’s Army Corps and the Military Police School — and, for decades, a major site of U.S. military chemical and biological weapons training, next door to Anniston, Alabama, a city whose name would become synonymous with PCB contamination.

She was honorably discharged on August 12, 1972, as a specialist.

There is a temptation, in a case like hers, to weigh five months of band duty against a lifetime of claimed illness and find the proportion strange. This page resists it, because the documented record does not ask about proportion: exposure cases on this wall turn on what was in the ground and water where a soldier was stationed, not on how long the station lasted or how martial the duty. The PCBs in Anniston did not check enlistment lengths. She filed her first applications weeks after her discharge — she has never been a late claimant manufacturing a connection in hindsight. She began asking in 1972, before Monsanto’s name and Anniston’s were linked in public, before anyone had told her a word about PCBs.

What happened

The health record she carried into those applications, as her congressman would later lay it before the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee, is this: fibromyalgia, autoimmune disorders, and asthma. She underwent a hysterectomy at thirty-seven. In 1991, a life-threatening stomach blockage required an operation that forced her retirement from General Electric, ending her working life. She has lived since on disability payments and a small pension — divorced, with no children — which frames her benefits fight exactly: it was never a survivor’s claim or a widow’s pension. It was her subsistence, the income she lived on, adjudicated year after year by an office that kept finding it not owed.

Her words for the sum of it, recorded in the Albany Times Union’s 2011 account of her thirty-nine-year battle, are the ones she has used for decades: “My life has been ruined, destroyed.”

Now the causation line, drawn as carefully here as anywhere on this wall. Frasier claims that toxic chemicals at Fort McClellan — the PCB contamination of Anniston above all — caused her illnesses. That claim is hers; it is consistent with PCB science in the assessment of Dr. David Carpenter of the University at Albany, a leading authority on PCB health effects; and it has never been adjudicated in her favor — not by the VA, not by a court. This page records the claim, the science she stands on, and the unbroken string of official refusals. It does not declare her proven.

What she did not have, for the first three decades, was even the knowledge to frame the claim. Monsanto’s Anniston plant had contaminated the surrounding community with PCBs for decades; in 2003, Monsanto settled the Anniston residents’ lawsuit for $700 million. Sue Frasier learned that a threat existed at all the way the troops of Fort McClellan were apprised of it — by accident, from television: a 2003 segment of 60 Minutes. No one ever notified the soldiers who had been stationed there. The residents of Anniston got a settlement and a cleanup record. The veterans who had marched, trained, eaten, and slept on the post next door got no letter, no registry, no notification program — nothing, until Frasier built the demand for one herself.

What the institution did afterward

The VA’s part of this record is short to state because it never changes: her applications, filed with the VA’s New York office beginning weeks after her 1972 discharge, were repeatedly rejected, and thirty-nine years later she was still appealing. The 2011 account is titled, flatly, “A Soldier’s 39-Year Battle.” She also sought an investigation of what she alleged was corruption in the handling of disability claims in that office. The VA declined to answer the newspaper’s questions about her case even with her signed permission for it to do so.

She took the fight to court on her own. In 2005, she filed suit pro se — representing herself — against Monsanto. It was dismissed. It was not the only one: the record counts at least eight self-filed actions thrown out because, living on disability and a small pension, she could not afford an attorney. A legal system that requires expertise she could not buy disposed of her cases without ever reaching the question she was asking.

And she took the fight to Congress, in person, at a tempo that deserves to be stated plainly. For years she rode an overnight Greyhound bus from Albany to Washington, alone, monthly, walked the halls of Congress asking members to examine the health records of Fort McClellan veterans, and rode home the same night. She did this on a fixed income, with fibromyalgia and asthma and the rest of her file, through her fifties and into her sixties. At sixty she was still riding. At sixty-four, in 2015, she was still advocating — she had, by then, finally gotten a meeting the process had refused her for years, and she was still pushing the same bill.

The bill exists because of her. Rep. Paul Tonko, who met Frasier shortly after his first election in 2008, has testified to the House Veterans’ Affairs Committee — in 2018, on the record — that her story brought the Fort McClellan issue to him: “Sue described for me the numerous health problems she had experienced since her time at Fort McClellan, including fibromyalgia, autoimmune disorders, and asthma. Most significantly, Sue had to undergo a hysterectomy at age 37. Sue’s story is not an isolated one.” Her years as lead spokesperson for Fort McClellan veterans became, in the Albany account’s phrase, the guiding reference for Tonko’s Fort McClellan Health Registry Act — legislation that would do the two things the institution never did on its own: notify everyone who served at Fort McClellan between 1935 and 1999 that they may have been exposed, and create a voluntary health registry and study to assess their claims.

Where it stands now

The Registry Act was introduced in 2010, again in 2015, again in 2018, and again in 2021. It died in committee every time. Four Congresses; four deaths without a vote on the merits that would answer her.

The VA’s institutional position, stated in a 2025 Board of Veterans’ Appeals decision, remains the wall she has been riding a bus against for decades: the VA “does not presume that any adverse health conditions are associated with service at Fort McClellan.” No presumption. No registry. No notification. Each Fort McClellan veteran files alone and proves alone — including the woman who has been proving, and filing, since 1972.

The last reporting in the record before this page finds Sue Frasier alive and advocating in 2015, at sixty-four years old. This page writes her as what she is: a living veteran whose case is not a tragedy to be summarized but a file still open — hers. The band played for five months in 1970. The appeals have run for more than half a century’s worth of her adult life. Somewhere in Washington there is a committee drawer with her bill in it, four times over. She has outlasted every Congress that buried it. The documented record suggests she intends to keep going.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door