IN MEMORY OF THOMAS ALAN BOWMAN SR. U.S. Navy Veteran He was promised. They never delivered. His story →
BETRAYED BY THE VA Thomas Alan Bowman Sr. asked his country for help. He got silence. Sign the demand →

Donald P. Sloat: The Grenade, the Lost Nomination, and the Medal That Came 44 Years Late

English · Español · Français · Italiano · 中文 · Tiếng Việt · Tagalog

Donald P. Sloat was twenty years old, a machine gunner from Coweta, Oklahoma, when a booby-trapped grenade rolled down a hill toward his squad in the Que Son Valley. He picked it up, found Americans in front of him and behind him, and pulled it into his own body. He was nominated for the Medal of Honor in 1970. The nomination then went nowhere, and for nearly forty years his own family believed he had stepped on a land mine. This page is the documented record of what he did, what the record shows about the award that did not follow, and what it took — new witness accounts, an act of Congress, and a mother who did not live to see it — to set the record right on September 15, 2014, forty-four years late.

The service, and the promise

Donald Paul Sloat was born February 6, 1949, in Coweta, Oklahoma. He grew up big — over six feet tall — played football, graduated from Coweta High School in 1967, and attended Northeastern Oklahoma A&M College in Miami, Oklahoma. Coweta would lose eight young men in Vietnam, and by its own account suffered the highest per-capita Vietnam casualty rate in the nation. Sloat was one of three Coweta men killed within the space of a single month.

He did not have to serve, and the Army at first would not take him. A physical showed high blood pressure, and he was rejected. He kept going back — to the doctor and then to the recruiter — until medication brought his blood pressure under enough control for him to pass. His brother Bill Sloat remembered that he tried at least five times; at the White House ceremony in 2014, President Barack Obama put the figure at perhaps seven attempts. The two accounts differ on the number. They agree on the fact: Donald Sloat was determined to serve his country, and he enlisted on March 19, 1969.

He trained at Fort Polk, Louisiana, and arrived in Vietnam in September 1969. The Army assigned him as an M60 machine gunner with 3rd Platoon, Company D, 2nd Battalion, 1st Infantry Regiment, 196th Light Infantry Brigade, Americal Division. His company operated from Fire Support Base Hawk Hill, southwest of Da Nang, providing security for villages and searching for North Vietnamese forces across terrain that ran from coastal lowlands into mountains and jungle. The men spent weeks at a time on patrol, in monsoon rain, and booby traps and snipers produced regular casualties.

The promise made to a soldier in that position is the oldest one the Army makes: that what a soldier does will be seen, recorded, and answered. Sloat kept his side of it in his first months. Twice, his patrol was ambushed. Both times, he exposed himself to enemy fire and answered with his machine gun. The Army recognized those actions with the Bronze Star Medal with “V” device and the Army Commendation Medal with “V” device. In a letter home in December 1969, he made little of it: “I guess they think I’m really gung-ho or something.” By January 1970, the men around him already knew what kind of soldier they had. He had less than four months in Vietnam behind him, and, as it turned out, days left to live — he died less than a month before his twenty-first birthday.

What happened

On the morning of January 17, 1970, Sloat’s squad was conducting a patrol in the Que Son Valley, serving as a blocking element in support of tanks and armored personnel carriers in the area. The squad was already understrength, operating at roughly two-thirds strength. As the men moved up a small hill in file formation, the lead soldier — the squad leader, Sgt. William “Bill” Hacker, running point — tripped a wire attached to a hand grenade booby trap set by enemy forces.

Both Hacker and Sloat shouted a warning. The noise of nearby .50-caliber guns drowned them out, and the other men never heard it.

The grenade rolled down the hill toward Sloat. What happened next is recorded in the official Medal of Honor citation in plain language. Sloat knelt and picked up the grenade. He initially attempted to throw it. He then realized that detonation was imminent — and that there were Americans in front of him and behind him, inside the kill zone, so that throwing it could simply move the blast from one group of soldiers to another. There was no safe place to send it.

He drew the grenade to his body and shielded his squad members from the blast.

The explosion killed Sloat. It seriously wounded Sgt. William Hacker, Elwood Tipton, and DeWayne C. Lewis Jr., and it knocked Spc. Michael W. Muhlheim off his feet and left him temporarily senseless. Four men were medically evacuated. Every other member of the squad survived. The single explosion took out half of a squad that had started the patrol at only two-thirds strength — and Sloat had absorbed the worst of it, with his own body, on purpose.

Lewis was only five to eight feet behind him. “It is my firm belief that I would not be alive today (except) for the heroic act that Don did that day,” Lewis later stated. “I was only five to eight feet behind Don when the grenade went off. This act saved my life.” Muhlheim, who got up the trail checking each wounded man until he reached Sloat and found him dead, spent the rest of his life, in the Army’s own reconstruction, trying to forget what he saw.

Sloat died in the Que Son Valley on January 17, 1970, three weeks short of his twenty-first birthday. His name came home to Coweta on a casualty notification. What did not come home was the truth of how he died.

What the institution did afterward

The notification team that came to the Sloat home told the family that Don had been killed in action on January 17, 1970, when he stepped on a land mine. His older brother Bill picked up his three younger siblings from school and broke the news in those terms. The family mourned him, honored him, and lived with that version of his death for nearly forty years.

The record shows something else happened inside the Army in 1970, and then stopped happening. Sloat’s heroism was recognized at the time closely enough for a Medal of Honor nomination to exist. The nomination was real. Then it went nowhere.

That sentence is the whole of what the documented record establishes, and this page will not add to it. No evidence has ever identified the person who stopped the nomination, the office where it stalled, or the reason the recommendation died. Those facts have never been produced — not in 1970, and not in the reconstruction four decades later. Any account that names a culprit, an office, or a motive is inventing one, and the Army’s own later reconstruction does not do so. What is documented is the outcome: a soldier had been recommended for the nation’s highest military decoration after giving his life for his squad, the award process failed to carry that recommendation through, and his family was left with a land mine that never existed.

The truth came back almost by accident, decades later. A cousin stumbled across an online tribute to Sloat and found an account that did not match the story the family had known — an account describing Don dying while protecting other soldiers from a grenade. Only a few weeks later, Michael W. Muhlheim called Sloat’s mother, Evelyn Sloat.

That telephone call had taken decades. Muhlheim had survived the explosion, but that morning had affected him so deeply that he had never been able to bring himself to call the family and tell them what happened. He finally summoned the strength to do it. He told Evelyn that her son had smothered the grenade to save the men around him. And he told her something else: Don had been nominated for the Medal of Honor.

Evelyn Sloat had already buried a second grief — she had lost her 12-year-old son Bruce to a freak accident at a baseball game years before Donald’s death. The news that Donald had died a hero, in her family’s account, rejuvenated her. She made proper recognition of her son’s actions her mission.

Rebuilding the case took years. Witness accounts and records had to be assembled for an action four decades old — the sworn testimony of the men who had been on that hill, including Lewis, five to eight feet behind Sloat when the grenade went off. And the age of the case created a second obstacle: federal law imposes time limits on Medal of Honor recommendations and presentation, and those limits had long since run. Congress had to clear the obstacle before the award could proceed. In 2013, lawmakers approved legislation waiving the time limits for Sloat and for fellow Vietnam veteran Bennie G. Adkins.

Evelyn Sloat died in 2011. She had already bought a special dress to wear when her son finally received the recognition she believed was coming. She died three years before it happened. Her children credit the quest itself with keeping her alive for quite some time.

Where it stands now

On September 15, 2014, in the East Room of the White House, President Barack Obama posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor to Specialist Four Donald P. Sloat. His brother, Dr. Bill Sloat of Enid, Oklahoma, accepted the medal on his behalf. Two men who were on the patrol that morning — Sgt. William Hacker and Spc. Michael Muhlheim — were present. The following day, Dr. Bill Sloat accepted his brother’s Hall of Heroes citation at the Pentagon induction ceremony.

At the ceremony, the President stated the delay plainly: “Normally, the Medal of Honor must be awarded within a few years of the action. But sometimes even the most extraordinary stories can get lost in the fog of war, or the passage of time. Yet, when new evidence comes to light, certain actions can be reconsidered for this honor, and it is entirely right and proper that we have done so.” He closed Sloat’s portion of the ceremony with the family’s loss inside the correction: “For decades, Don’s family only knew that he was killed in action. They’d heard that he had stepped on a landmine. Late in her life, Don’s mother, Evelyn, finally learned the full story of her son’s sacrifice. And she made it her mission to have Don’s actions properly recognized. Sadly, nearly three years ago, Evelyn passed away. But she always believed — she knew — that this day would come.”

Bill Sloat’s own words, recorded by the Army, were plainer: “It’s Don’s award, but we feel like it’s Mom’s story. It’s a true honor, but people are people. Whether he was the Medal of Honor [recipient] or not, he was my brother, and I would much rather have my brother than what’s happening for him now.” Muhlheim said he was “very happy” and “amazed” — “After all of that time I thought that it could never happen. I feel like this medal represents the stories that will never be told.”

Sloat rests at Vernon Cemetery in Coweta. In 2017, his family brought his Medal of Honor and several of his other military decorations home to Coweta for permanent display at City Hall, so that the people of his hometown could see them. Forty-four years after January 17, 1970, the medal exists, the citation exists, and the record of what Donald Sloat did is now the official record. What does not exist — what has never existed — is any accounting of where his 1970 nomination went, or why. That part of the record is still blank, and it is blank in the institution’s own files, not in his family’s telling.

The ledger

The accounting, in three lines — what the record shows has been done, what it shows has not, and what is still being sought.

What has been done

What has not been done

What is being sought

Sources

Part of Betrayed, Not Forgotten — this site's accounting for the service members and veterans their own institutions failed.

The Whistleblower Door

Three doors, one intake — your story, under permissions you set. Inside the system instead? You have a protected door of your own: The Whistleblower Door — a statement line, and the law that protects the people who use it.

+1 (386) 251-1318 The Whistleblower Door